Thanks for the info, everyone! I really appreciate it!!
I will definitely try the gazelle since someone on here can verify it.
If I knew how to work eBay, and not get screwed over, I probably would!! Since i'm a 22 year old girl in Mississippi, with a bunch of crazy hicks, Craigslist is definitely not an option because i'd be scared lol
Thanks so much again, and I'll let y'all know!! I can buy it, but I'm hoping I may have worked something out with an AT&T rep today because the one i spoke to one yesterday who blatantly told me that'd it'd make more sense for me to pay my ETF and move to another carrier, than pay out of contract price since I have problems with my iPhone 4. So I thanked him and hung up, called back today and complained and the manager was extremely nice and said they didn't want to see me leave after so long and they'd call me Monday around 10 am to offer me the discounted price, but I would have to agree to a new contract and it was only offered through customer service. I'm not getting my hopes up, though!!