I figured I would start a thread for Case reviews. Here is the one I got today.
Amazon.com: WIRELESS CENTRAL Brand Matte Snap-On BLACK RUBBERIZED Hard Case Cover For SAMSUNG M950 GALAXY REVERB VIRGIN MOBILE With PRY-Triangle Case Removal Tool [WCJ264]: Cell Phones & Accessories
Overall the case is adequate. The fit is not quite as snug as I would like. Functionally it seems to get the job done, but I have a feeling the case is going to break after a drop or 2. I will update accordingly.
The case is not rubbery/grippy. This is actually what I wanted, as trying to pull a silicone/rubber case out of a jeans pocket makes me want to throw it across the room when it finally comes out.
Not a bad case for <$5 shipped. 3.5/5.0 for me
Edit: The wiggle is annoying me, going to be buying another case to see if I can find one that fits better.