View Single Post
Old February 10th, 2013, 01:01 AM   #26 (permalink)
yfan
Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Posts: 195
 
Device(s):
Carrier: Not Provided

Thanks: 14
Thanked 37 Times in 27 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by mikedt View Post
I'm going to be consuming data either on my smart-phone or my PC. The modern smart phone is a computer. For my uses, I don't think I'm going to be using any more on either. So why should I have to pay extra for the data coming from my laptop, over what's coming from my smart-phone?
Because you are using the data on a different device that you prefer. You can make all the arguments you want, but you can't get around the fact that you *want* to use the data on other devices and not on the phone. The whole point is that if you aren't using that data on the phone, you are not jamming up the network (supposedly, assuming you abide by your contract). You want the option to jam up the network no matter what device you use, and that's not cool. Usage patterns are built into the data assumptions that carriers make - assumptions that go into building their network capacity, as well as determining their prices. Carriers assume that the phone is not your main movie watching device. It can be, but it usually isn't - even in your case because you want to watch it on a bigger, better screen. If you are using the data no matter where you're watching it, then you are hogging the network with a device not authorized to be on the network.

Once again, IF you think you would use all the data on the phone anyway, then by all means, use it on the phone.

Quote:
TBH I've never had to pay extra for tethering, not in the UK or China. Is it mainly a US carrier thing, because they can get away with it? I know 3 in the UK charges extra for tethering, but then that's not a particularly good carrier, and will gouge for everything, not just tethering.
In the UK, there don't seem to be any unlimited data plans at all. On a limited data plan, I could possibly see the case for free tethering, but not on unlimited plans.

Quote:
BTW I've just pre-paid for another month, the China Mobile doesn't care what I do with the SIM or what I use it for, I can use it in my phone, tether it, or I can even put it in a 3G modem and use it purely for data. On my particular plan the internet is metered by the number of hours I use, and not the amount of data.
So you do have some sort of metering. Unlimited, unthrottled plans don't (hence they are unlimited and unthrottled). Even your provider does bandwidth management. Your beef seems to be with the way that some American providers do the same thing.
yfan is offline  
Reply With Quote