It sounds like you have a magnifier on or something...
dngrsone@Dads ~ $ sudo umount /dev/sda5
[sudo] password for dngrsone:
dngrsone@Dads ~ $ sudo extundelete --restore-all --after 1381960800 /dev/sda5
Only show and process deleted entries if they are deleted on or after 1381960800 and before 9223372036854775807.
extundelete: failed to read-only open device "/dev/sda5": Error code 2133571347
This is what I get. I am thinking I have to do something with the inodes, but that is way outside my knowledge...