Should you buy a Nexus 5 on Craigslist?
Nope! That 'like new' Nexus 5 is probably a water damaged phone that had a digitizer replaced just like your Note 3 will. Wouldn't be surprised if your Note 3 winds up for sale on craigslist as 'like new'.
She said, "Is that a Note 3 in your pocket or are you just excited to see me?"