Thank you very much for the response. It worked very well and your instructions were easy to follow!
I'm curious as to how this happened, if anyone cares if they have the same issue, or if it even matters (am I losing any benefits by having it on device and google)? I just didn't need to see all of those extra icons next to my contact's name. It was also a pain to see so many of the exact same numbers showing up when I looked at my contact's phone numbers.