View Single Post
Old May 11th, 2010, 02:44 PM   #62 (permalink)
Silvertag
Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Montreal
Posts: 185
 
Device(s): Samsung Captivate 4.0.3 ICS OneCosmic RC4.2 Kernel Icy Glitch V14 B5
Thanks: 1
Thanked 19 Times in 17 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by mjschmidt View Post
I think this brings up a very important question, one I doubt Rogers will answer.

Now that we can root the E911 phones, and now that we may possibly be able to load the Dream radio and keep our data... that means that we can all run versions of Android that are not the "officially approved" version Rogers would prefer we run.

Rogers made us upgrade because the previously existing version of Android we had suffered from a bug that could cause the phone to crash when dialing 911.

We know that the 1.6 and up ROMs have (or should have anyway) the fix in them, but Rogers wouldn't let us have data without either applying the E911 update, or signing a waiver.

Now that we can theoretically root and install a non-E911 OS version, and get data without signing the waiver... it stands to reason, logically, that Rogers must force another update to block root again and force another "official" version on us... otherwise they cannot justify cutting off data (or requiring the waiver) until/unless we have the E911 update, because rooting simply puts them back into that potential legal trap that existed because of the E911 bug.

It's a double-standard, just like allowing jailbroken iPhones on their network.
I don't think they will do another round of force-upgrace. The whole E911 was really just a "Oh oh our lawyers told us to cover our arses ASAP and we will" moment. They could of been sued if one of their user died in a emergency because of this issue and they rushed a update, spammed our sms boxes with warning and cut the data to make sure they cover their bases. Was it badly handled.. yes it was but the advisers who told Rogers to make a move to patch this problem don't care about customer experience they care about how much money business lose and dirty press they could get.

I'm running a 2.1 rom, for the last 3 months, on a 6.35 radio that is higher then the E911 one and did not lost my data. The problem will go away by itself when the 2.1 upgrade comes around. There will be no need to flag this update as the patch for the E911 is already there. The remaining users still using the non-patched update or running a inferior firmware rom will still get flagged because of the above paragraph.
Silvertag is offline  
Reply With Quote