Recently picked up the case mate tough case for the incredible. First thing I'll say is this is an excellent case. It comes with a silicon sleeve with a hard plastic shell that fits over it, basically the exact same setup as the seidio active case. I currently have the black seidio active case and comparing the two I'd say this case is definitely the better of the two. It's the details that make it better. Both the sleeve and the hard shell have a smooth satin like feel and doesn't feel as rubbery as the seidio sleeve. The power and volume buttons are more recessed than the seidio case yet the buttons are more responsive and don't take as much effort to register a press, especially the power button. The headphone plug has a better cut-out. The hard shell has raised texturing that make it feels good and also gives a more confident feeling of grip. Honestly the only reason to choose the seidio case over this one would be if you really want a color other than black. If case mate offers theirs in different color then seidio might as well stop making theirs, the case mate case is that much better and it's the same price. Any questions let me know. On with the pics...