Device(s): Samsung Galaxy S III
Debloated SynergyROM (Nightly) R64
Carrier: Not Provided
Thanks: 7
Thanked 60 Times in 18 Posts
Incredible v.s Droid X v.s Fascinate v.s Droid 2
so while i was waiting around the verizon store to make a purchase and complain about the 3g problem, i had a little time to download Quadrant and do some benchmarking.
i think its laughable both at how the ALL NEW AND MASSIVELY IMPROVED DROID X is hardly above the "out of date" Incredible. also, how pathetic the Droid 2 is. 777. I dont even know where to begin.
right, i can run it 3 times on my phone and they will vary 300 from each other. It can be decent sometimes if you run it enough to get an estimate but even still its not scientific at all really.
Not apples to apples, this here comparison (though I like the layout). The Fascinate is 2.1 and also has a lag issue due to a Wiz problem, but there is a fix for it. I have an Inc with 2.2 and non-OC'd BFS kernel. My average is 1200.... if the benchmarks can be trusted in the first place. I still suggest they are a placebo- to some degree.
Still I can keep running it (not backing out and killing the task) and get upper 1300's and then post that as my number- like a lot people do In fact, though my scores are usually around 1200 average, I just now got a 1371 average after running concurrent tests and not backing out of the app I guess I will post THAT as my score
Did the global warming alarmists use similar testing methods?? Oh yeah, sorry- that did not pan out, so they are now trying to brand it, "climate disruption"
Average running concurrent and not backing out = 1371
Average backing out and killing the app = 1200
BTW, that low number for the D2 is an outlier by about 400 points from other tests- again assuming the benchmarks are accurate or Ghost Hunter level accurate (not real). BTW, no offense to Quandrant, since not implying the same quasi-silliness as GHs.
Last edited by rushmore; September 21st, 2010 at 08:12 AM.
Not apples to apples, this here comparison (though I like the layout). The Fascinate is 2.1 and also has a lag issue due to a Wiz problem, but there is a fix for it. I have an Inc with 2.2 and non-OC'd BFS kernel. My average is 1200.... if the benchmarks can be trusted in the first place. I still suggest they are a placebo- to some degree.
Still I can keep running it (not backing out and killing the task) and get upper 1300's and then post that as my number- like a lot people do In fact, though my scores are usually around 1200 average, I just now got a 1371 average after running concurrent tests and not backing out of the app I guess I will post THAT as my score
Did the global warming alarmists use similar testing methods?? Oh yeah, sorry- that did not pan out, so they are now trying to brand it, "climate disruption"
Average running concurrent and not backing out = 1371
Average backing out and killing the app = 1200
BTW, that low number for the D2 is an outlier by about 400 points from other tests- again assuming the benchmarks are accurate or Ghost Hunter level accurate (not real). BTW, no offense to Quandrant, since not implying the same quasi-silliness as GHs.
most users wont care, but it seems that when people load a new rom, kernel etc this is the first test they run and then brag about how great the kernel or rom is. So while many people turn to the app for comparisons, its really not a true test
quadrant is all over the board on my phone. I think it depends what 2.2 chose to open and run in background. personally I could care less. Droid phone is solid so droid is a nice choice fascinate felt plasticy and droid X won fit in my pocket and I sure am not putting it on my belt.
hey, i thought it was interesting and not a waste of time, for what it's worth.
i like any stat that lists the incredible well .
but yeah, it seems like the X is touted as an all-supreme phone, when at this point it's just a little faster. Both devices have pros and cons.
it seems like the X has better battery life, which is one of the reasons i was thinking about switching to the X. I love the incredible's camera, though. great stuff.
Droid X with the OTA froyo that just came out yesterday......1405 quadrant.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ACD168
I will take a little slower phone that can be overclocked and custom ROM. than a big fat X
Oh and the Droid X can have custom ROMs now and can be overclocked with a free app from the market. Up to 1150mhz, but obviously you have to be rooted.
Last edited by ZXMustang; September 22nd, 2010 at 10:11 AM.
Device(s): Droid X1, Droid 1, RAZR, Rezound, Maxx HD
Carrier: Not Provided
Thanks: 4,146
Thanked 355 Times in 275 Posts
After that stage fright hack in the buildprop for the Droid and X.....I dont really trust Quadrant scores anymore.
After hearing some ppl say they did the lag fix for the Samsung phones....and it didnt help with any lag they were having...I dont really trust Quadrant scores anymore.
Maybe like some have said, for gpu tests only. Maybe.
__________________
The ultimate measure of a man is not where he stands in moments of comfort and convenience, but where he stands at times of challenge and controversy.
MLK, Jr.
Last edited by jroc; September 22nd, 2010 at 03:05 PM.
Incredible v.s Droid X v.s Fascinate v.s Droid 2
In fact, though my scores are usually around 1200 average, I just now got a 1371 average after running concurrent tests and not backing out of the app 
I guess I will post THAT as my score 
