Last Updated:

  1. Josepho1997

    Josepho1997 Guest

    I've been told that .999...=1 (.999... means .9999 repeating)
    What do you think? Does. 9999=1?

  2. Mikestony

    Mikestony ~30% Carbon Black ± Moderator

    It's close enough for me, but .999.... is repeating to me, so no, it does not equal "1". "1" = 1.0000000.... My opinion anyhoo:p
  3. jhawkkw

    jhawkkw Chinchillin' Moderator

    .99999... does in fact equal 1 and can be easily mathematically proved.

    Let x=.9999999......
    Therefore 10x=9.99999.......
    10x-x =9x. == 9.99999.....-.999999....=9
    So 9x=9
    ScandaLeX, Sak01, ocnbrze and 2 others like this.
  4. Mikestony

    Mikestony ~30% Carbon Black ± Moderator

  5. jhawkkw

    jhawkkw Chinchillin' Moderator

    Following the same set if steps, you would end up with 9x =2. Thus x =2\9, which is indeed what. 2222222..... is equal to.
    Sak01, ocnbrze and Mikestony like this.
  6. olbriar

    olbriar Moderator Moderator

    ocnbrze likes this.
  7. scary alien

    scary alien not really so scary Moderator

    ocnbrze and psionandy like this.
  8. Mikestony

    Mikestony ~30% Carbon Black ± Moderator

    Tell me if I'm wrong here:
    10x= 2.22222222......
    10x-x=9x 2.22222222.....-.2222222222= 2
    divide each side by 9
    back to where we started

    ah, I think I get it...
    .99999999.....would be the only number equal to 1?:confused:
  9. jhawkkw

    jhawkkw Chinchillin' Moderator

    Correct, it is an odd situation that comes up in mathematics. There others out there too, but I will spare everyone the messy details because the proofs involve higher mathematics and aren't easy to type. This method shown above can be used to figure out the fraction for any repeating decimal. Pretty nifty I'd say.
    ocnbrze and Mikestony like this.
  10. Mikestony

    Mikestony ~30% Carbon Black ± Moderator

    I knew I should've taken math a little further in school :p

    Thanks jhawk :)
  11. Mikestony

    Mikestony ~30% Carbon Black ± Moderator

  12. Prinny

    Prinny Resident Linux Nutcase

    I like how one of the tags is "trolls." o.o

    This was an awesome thread. Great read. It makes total sense.
    ocnbrze likes this.
  13. h4x0rj3ff

    h4x0rj3ff Chemist

    It depends on the setting really. If your manufacturing gears with a wire edm then .9999 is still .0001 underside from 1.00000. now if you have a geometric tolerance of lets say +- .00001 than that dimention being at .9999 would bring you out of tolerance by .00009 rendering the part non conforming and scrap.
  14. jhawkkw

    jhawkkw Chinchillin' Moderator

    Partially true. .9999 itself is not equal to 1. But the idea behind the question and the proof is for .9999...., meaning repeating infinitely forever and is absolutely 100% true.
  15. h4x0rj3ff

    h4x0rj3ff Chemist

    Also its not repeating unless it uses ~ above the last number :)
  16. jhawkkw

    jhawkkw Chinchillin' Moderator

    That is one way to show repeating decimals, but the ellipses "..." is also widely accepted in mathematics to signify a repeating sequence.
  17. DaSchmarotzer

    DaSchmarotzer Blame it on me VIP Member

    It's been said already, but it's true.

    You can also see it even more easily like this:

    (1/3) + (1/3) + (1/3) = 1

    0.3333... + 0.333333... + 0.333... = 1


    0.999999..... = 1

    It also works with other numbers that end with a decimal periodic 9. Such as:
    23.56999999.... = 23.57
    scary alien and ocnbrze like this.
  18. mikedt

    mikedt 你好 Guide

  19. psionandy

    psionandy Well-Known Member VIP Member

    thats only true if you assume 0.3333... = 1/3
    which (depending on context, may or may not be true

    There are 10 types of people in the world.. those that count in binary, and those that don't.
    ocnbrze likes this.
  20. jhawkkw

    jhawkkw Chinchillin' Moderator

    1/3 is exactly = .333... repeated for ever and you can easily discover that for yourself by dividing 1 by 3. If you do it manually using the standard you will constantly get repeating 3's forever until you decide you've had enough punishment.

    I wanted to avoid the use of higher mathematics, but the reason behind the equality is stated right in the wiki article:

    Whether anyone chooses to accept it or not is their choice, but nonetheless, it is 100% true. I often run into non-believers when I teach this topic in the Infinite Series part of Calculus II, granted the proof for that class is different giving the context of the class.
    DaSchmarotzer and ocnbrze like this.
  21. scary alien

    scary alien not really so scary Moderator

    One can look at all of the Notes, References, Further Reading, and External links listed in the wiki page.

  22. jhawkkw

    jhawkkw Chinchillin' Moderator

    I could give you the real reason, but would require the use of real analysis which is usually a 4th year mathematics course. As I stated earlier, it has to deal with the fact that there is no non-zero infinitesimal between .999... and 1.0. In other words, there is no number between .999... and 1.
    For the purpose of a proof, lets assume they are distinct numbers. For any number not ending in a infinite sequence of 9's, you can always find another number in between two different numbers by simply finding the midpoint (x1+x2)/2. This doesn't work with numbers ending in the infinite sequence of 9's because the midpoint between .9 and 1 is .95. so if you could take the midpoint of the two, following that idea, the last number would have to be a 5, which contradicts the whole notion because .999 is an infinite sequence of 9's and would actually be greater than our midpoints. This creates an absurdity, which many mathematicians call a proof by contradiction. So since our original idea about them being two different numbers let to a contradiction, that means that assumption must be false, and thus means they have to be the same number.
    jayb123x, Sak01, dan330 and 1 other person like this.
  23. Liamo_210

    Liamo_210 Well-Known Member

    Without a doubt .999 =1 it can be mathematicaly proved as shown above. .222 does not =1 nor does .3333 .444 etc. Again all this was said above but i thought i would verify it.
    ocnbrze likes this.
  24. psionandy

    psionandy Well-Known Member VIP Member

    well.. in that case pie is 3.14 :p

    or whatever number you get before you decide you've had enough punishment.
    or 3.2 if you're a stupid person from indiana
    Indiana Pi Bill - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    ocnbrze, Mikestony and scary alien like this.
  25. scary alien

    scary alien not really so scary Moderator

    Hey, I'm from Indiana! :mad:

    Oh, wait--that means....nooooooooooo! :eek: :p ;) :) :D

    Glad that all happened way back 1897 ;) :).
    EarlyMon, Mikestony and ocnbrze like this.

Share This Page