I am currently using the VZW Hard Shell/Holster combo, and love having the holster, but I'm nervous about the level off protection the shell actually provides. I'd like something similar, but a lot more protection. Bulk doesn't really bother me. I also know everyone is going to say Otterbox, but the Defender isn't out yet, and the Commuter doesn't have a clip/holster. If either was a choice at the moment I would buy them.