Desire HD replacement

[batfinkgtr]

Hi,

Currently got a Desire HD, but getting fed up with it now, consistently dropping the mobile network if making a call, and the poor battery life, which not even a new battery seemed to solve.

So looking at buying a replacement, still within contract, so going the replacement route.

Shortlist:

Sensation XE
Sensation XL
Galaxy S2

So what are the thoughts? I am in the UK if that makes any difference. I like the HTC's solid feel, and don't like the Galaxy which feels plasticy and just too light.

I know the XE has a bigger battery than the XL, but according to comparisons elsewhere, the XL actually lasts longer, presumably due to the single core processor. I'm thinking though the a dual core processor will be better for the future??

Just hoping for tips and advice, I know a phone is a personal thing. Hoping to visit a CPW at lunchtime to see these in the flesh.

Thanks.

Gary

 

[El Presidente]

The S2 is easily the best phone of the 3, but like yourself, I prefer the feel of HTC handsets. I suppose if you were to put a decent case on there, it wouldn't make much of a difference?

I remember reading a phandroid article stating you don't really notice the single core in the XL as it's pretty slick, but for future proofing, dual will probably be better.

So, to summarise, I don't know There is nothing really wrong with any of those phones, it's just a case of heading to CPW and seeing which one feels right. You might also want to take a look at the Galaxy Note? It's like a bigger version of the S2 but due to its size, it doesn't feel as cheap.

 

[batfinkgtr]

Thanks.

Popped in to CPW and non the wiser really. Galaxy S2 looks good, but feels like a toy and suspected. XL is huge, even compared with the HD. They didnt have an XE. All a similar price on sim free, guess its the toss of a coin time then.

 

[john_g]

Presumably you've looked through the forums here to see what's being said about these phones?

Here are a few websites I bookmarked because they've proved helpful in the past when I was researching my next phone upgrade. I've not checked whether they've reviewed the models you're interested in though.

Trusted Reviews - The Latest Technology News and Reviews
GSMArena.com - GSM phone reviews, news, opinions, votes, manuals and more...
Mobile-review.com
Mobile Phone Reviews LetsGoMobile

 

[batfinkgtr]

Hi John_g.

Yep, reviewed the forums, but unfortunately most people only post when they have a problem, so somewhere like this makes most phone look like a crock of poo, when clearly that isnt the case.

From the reading I have done, looks like the Galaxy is the best, I just dont like it's light and plastic feel.

So at the moment, its either XE or XL, hmmmm

Will review the links you posted, thanks.

Gary

 

[SB13X]

Personally I think your wasting your money. There is nothing any of the phones on offer will do that will make them seem comparatively awe inspiring. I'd keep the money for a rainy day or at least until this beast arrives:

Quad-Core HTC Edge Receives a Name Change

That is the only handset either available now or on the horizon I'd consider replacing my DHD with and should you go for a Sensation with dual core when we are on the brink of quadcore going into mass production it imho would be a big mistake.

 

[malcster]

I can upgrade after16 months in Feb but I might wait until my 18 months is up in April and look into a edge or what ever its called

Thanks for the info ..

 

[batfinkgtr]

Thanks for the information, looks like I might hold off for a few weeks and see what gets announced. That new phone looks interesting, be good to see the final specs, and an expected UK street price.

 

[Deleted User]

I live in a very bad reception area and yet I have never had a the mobile network drop whilst on a call, I think you need to talk to your provider before spending money.