Hey peeps. I was just roaming around to see what actual users think about the X. I had a DINC for 3 weeks but took it back because the actual telephone part of it didn't work. Cost me $55 in re-stock fees and to re-activate my BBerry, which hurt, but at least I can travel around Los Angeles and be able to place, receive, and maintain phone calls reliably again.
I was really hoping that since Motorola made the X, that it would have a better radio in it. But from what I've been reading, it seems to have almost exactly the same problems even though it's got completely different hardware.
So I guess I'll suffer along with my beat up old Blackberry until the NEXT new awesome Android phone comes along on Verizon. Or wait and see if it really is a software issue with 2.1 that can be fixed with a firmware update, and then I might go back and pick up an X or another Incredible since I like everything about them so much...but reliable telephone service is absolutely essential.
FWIW, I live about 2000 feet from a Verizon tower. With the DINC sitting on my desk it almost never had more than one bar, rarely 3G, and was unreliable as a telephone. Meanwhile, my 8330 Curve was getting full bars and was perfectly reliable for voice. I don't want to repeat that cycle all over again, so it sounds like the X is not ready for prime time yet, and neither is the Incredible, so I suspect there's an issue with Verizon and all 2.1 Android phones in certain markets. I can see the VZW tower from the roof of my house, and the phone part of it still didn't work well enough.
Sad to hear that so many people are having essentially the same problems with the X. Oh, and there's a corporate VZW store that's about 800 feet from the tower, and the demo X I played with showed minimal signal strength, just like the Incredible did.
Oh well. I still have a phone that works. A very boring phone, but I can drive all over LA including tunnels and canyons and maintain a phone call. When the Android phones work as well, I'll get one because they're pretty awesome, and I miss everything about the Incredible except unreliable telephony, and trouble reading the screen in broad daylight.
For me, a smartphone is a tool not a toy, and while I enjoy the toy aspects of the VZW Android devices, they just aren't very good tools. At least not where I live and work and need a cell PHONE I can count on.
BTW, a friend of mine just picked up an iPhone 4. He's left handed. I lost count of how many times I handed him my creaky old Blackberry so he could either place or continue an important phone call. Also a wondrous device, except for making phone calls with.