Google maps vs. Garmin my .02

Discussion in 'Android Apps & Games' started by sj24, May 7, 2010.

  1. sj24

    sj24 Active Member
    16

    May 5, 2010
    40
    1
    16
    Cape Cod
    Today I used google maps from my incredible to go to a store that i've been to before . Google had me get off at exit 9 as opposed to exit 10, exit 9 brought me through the center of town, approx 6 mins from the store. Garmin tells me to use exit 10 which is alot closer, store is less than 1 min from exit. Google seems to be more update on searches and locations because Garmin tells me that store in on left side of street but really is on right. The other day Google sent me down a dirt road, around a pond and through a cranberry bog even though a paved road was nearby, dirt road was more direct, definatly not easier. I guess Google from phone is good in a pinch but if I'm going away on a trip i'll definatly be bringing my trusty Garmin.
     

    Advertisement
  2. MisterMixelpix

    MisterMixelpix Well-Known Member
    103

    May 4, 2010
    774
    153
    103
    Youth Counselor
    PA
    I had the opposite experience. One time I had to go out to a loading job two towns over and my Garmin was under the impression that the parking lot behind a school was in fact a straight road that went through town. GMaps picked right up on it.

    Plus you have to buy updates for the Garmin, so... no thanks.
     
  3. SFBayArea

    SFBayArea Well-Known Member
    38

    May 4, 2010
    270
    16
    38
    I love Garmin, I had it on my Samsung Omnia and I just wish Garmin would come up with the software version for Android phones.
    Undoubted benefits of Garmin GPS software are:
    1. Automatic reroute when you miss the exit, unlike google where you have to come back to the missed exit or turn.
    2. Searches for the traffic like google, like google traffic is free, unlike google Garmin automatically guides you to avoid traffic congestions.
     
  4. MisterMixelpix

    MisterMixelpix Well-Known Member
    103

    May 4, 2010
    774
    153
    103
    Youth Counselor
    PA
    The Nav app doesn't automatically reroute?? Hell, VZ Navigator did that!!
     
  5. SFBayArea

    SFBayArea Well-Known Member
    38

    May 4, 2010
    270
    16
    38
    Google Navigator does not automatically reroute you. I know it seems silly not having this feature, but so is traffic avoidance, after all, Nav already can have layer of traffic, but it is too stupid to do auto avoidance. I expected better from Google :(.
     
  6. nightfishing

    nightfishing Well-Known Member
    93

    May 2, 2010
    588
    111
    93
    1. google nav has automatically rerouted me after I wavered from the given directions(my Garmin is VERY persistent on looping me back to any missed turn despite me screaming at it.)
    2. the traffic on my Garmin causes way more issues than it resolves. it has a nasty habit of dumping me on surface streets in the middle of cities which 99% of the time is a time loser vs. riding out the hghwy traffic.
    3. regardless, any phone app is not a suitable replacement for a standalone gps unit, but Garmin on Android is miles ahead of any other mobile option (pun intended)

    btw - I had the full Garmin on my BB and it was very nice, but Google Nav's integration with Google Maps online is so ridiculously convenient that it trumps the Garmin app by a wide margin. No more manually transferring saved maps and routes to POIs for my GPS unit and STILL having to manually enter them into the Garmin mobile app.
     
  7. UncleMike

    UncleMike Well-Known Member
    163

    Nov 15, 2009
    2,323
    482
    163
    Central NJ
    My experience is that Google Maps Navigation does reroute you if you miss a turn or otherwise don't follow the route.

    Garmin automatically routes you to avoid the traffic it knows about, which is often limited to major highways. In heavy traffic this can often result in a route that takes you on local roads, where Garmin is unaware of the traffic that has developed due to everyone else trying to avoid the same highway traffic.

    This problem is not unique to Garmin though. Any automatic routing around traffic will be flawed when the traffic information is incomplete. I think TomTom does a better job here, but it really comes down to how well it works for YOU in YOUR area.

    One thing I have focused on since having a Garmin I was unhappy with, is the guidance provided to keep you on the selected route. I find that Google does a good job with this, and TomTom as well, whereas Garmin does not. Again, much of this has to do with map quality in a particular area, and your personal preferences.
     
  8. hallstevenson

    hallstevenson Well-Known Member
    68

    Jan 5, 2010
    791
    26
    68
    Yes it does.
     
  9. MisterMixelpix

    MisterMixelpix Well-Known Member
    103

    May 4, 2010
    774
    153
    103
    Youth Counselor
    PA
    I figured it would. I'll test it out sometime for myself though.
     
  10. nomarsgirl

    nomarsgirl Well-Known Member
    78

    Mar 4, 2010
    671
    68
    78
    Red Sox Nation
    Google Navigator most definitely DOES reroute you automatically. It won't do it if you lose your data connection, however. That is the only advantage I see to my Garmin. The maps are already stored on it so I don't have to worry about a data connection. My Garmin maps are 2 years old now though and there is no way I'm paying for new ones.
     
  11. MisterMixelpix

    MisterMixelpix Well-Known Member
    103

    May 4, 2010
    774
    153
    103
    Youth Counselor
    PA
    That's what killed it for me. Either I drop $70 per year on new maps or about $150 for a "lifetime membership" on a device that doesn't last forever (my StreetPilot died on me about six months back). No way I'm doing that.
     
  12. takeshi

    takeshi Well-Known Member
    163

    Dec 6, 2009
    3,354
    282
    163
    Not in my experience. Google Maps Navigation not only reroutes but reroutes very quickly.
     
  13. wildland

    wildland Well-Known Member
    63

    Apr 10, 2010
    109
    55
    63
    Helicopter Pilot
    This is awesome, because it reminds me of my favorite XKCD comic...
     
  14. jradicle11

    jradicle11 That Guy
    VIP Member
    143

    Feb 6, 2010
    1,041
    113
    143
    Lifeguard
    Illinois
    It always reroutes me as well, not sure what they're talking about. Hell, it even says something along the lines of "Recalculating route."
     
  15. barrister89

    barrister89 Well-Known Member
    16

    Apr 30, 2010
    91
    4
    16
    VA
    I played with google nav and it works ok but my car has a 7" lcd screen and easy to type in addresses or select points on the map. The screen on my Incredible is just too small for my aging eyes.

    I have a Garmin I use in my truck and one thing I like about it is it will (usually) display the speed limit.
     
  16. kneemeister

    kneemeister New Member
    15

    Dec 6, 2009
    2
    0
    15
    BMET
    Pittsford MI
    Last weekend, Google had me "exit" the Indiana Toll Rd. and Ohio Turnpike at DOT access drives, both would have been sharp rights directly into steel gates.:rolleyes:
     
  17. SFBayArea

    SFBayArea Well-Known Member
    38

    May 4, 2010
    270
    16
    38
    I take part of my post above back, Google Nav does auto reroute. However, second point - auto re-route based on the traffic condition still stands.
     
  18. SFBayArea

    SFBayArea Well-Known Member
    38

    May 4, 2010
    270
    16
    38
    For the money - FREE I think GoogNav is great app, however, another point nobody seem to care, is that you will loose your navigation capabilities with GoogNav in the area that does not have good celltower reception.
    For instance I do a lot of camping trips in summer and in some areas there are no cell connection at all, that would put me at the disadvantage.
     

Share This Page

Loading...