MP4 Player: Recommendations request

[turbohobbit]

I'm looking for an MP4 player that I can use on my Desire to play movies that I have saved to the SD card. The most important thinbg for me is minimisation of vision-to-sound lag. I'm running Froyo and the movies are stored on a 32GB Sandisk card.

Any recommendations folks?

 

[gie62001]

also depends on what class your SD card is as this would limit the framerate you can watch on your desire. i mean if you want to watch 720p videos and you have lower than class 6 SD card then you will definitelly have a lag and maybe not even able to play those videos. so tell us what compression or source your videos are and your SD card class.
but as far as player is concerned you don't need specific player on desire to be able to play mp4 videos but you can try RockPlayer for free from the market or divX player to watch divx movies.
gives us more detail so then maybe our answers would be more accurate

EDIT: forgot to mention that im watching 720p compressed videos at 8mbps framerate and 29fps without any lag on buil-in player

 

[turbohobbit]

Good point well made! I don't know about the class of the card I'm afraid, I'm not sure how I can find that out (I've tried looking on the Sandisc site without much joy).

I'm watching films that I ripped from DVD using Wondershare DVD - iPod ripper (set for iPod Touch display of 480 x 320 as this is the closest I could find to the Desire display). The files are either:

Frame rate: 29fps
Audio bitrate: 125kbps
Audio sampling: 44kHz

or

Frame rate: 30fps
Audio bitrate: 95kbps
Audio sampling: 44kHz

The majority of the movies I'm watching are with these settings. As I said, my main concern is looking for a player which minimises visual / audio lag. The built-in player that comes with Froyo doesn't seem to recognise mp4 - I just get stripey green screens.

 

[turbohobbit]

Any recommendations folks?

 

[Zaichik]

I'm also looking for recommendations - I want to play back mp4 files recorded at best quality from cable TV using a Sandisk V-Mate memory card recorder. I'm not having any problems with stuttering or sound synch, but when I play back the videos on my Desire using the default ap through earphones, the sound is all swooshy. (I don't have the same problem with mp3s or the radio and the effect is not so noticeable through the Desire's speaker).

Would changing the ap I use or upgrading my memory card help with this problem?

 

[markfireblade97]

I ripped my Avatar DVD into AVI format as an experiment (using DVDfab) and Rockplayer runs that OK on the Desire - but you do need a decent spec microsd...

 

[turbohobbit]

Ok, thanks Mark. I think my SD card is up to it (I'd like to think a >

 

[Zaichik]

I've just downloaded the free version of Rockplayer and it plays my mp4 files OK, with the added benefit that the fit to screen actually works and doesn't cut off the top and bottom like the default ap does. The only drawbacks are the ads (which aren't in the paid version) and the red R logo in the corner of the screen. If I buy the paid ap, will it get rid of the logo as well as the ads?

If not, can you recommend another ap which has no logos and where the fit to screen actually works?

EDIT: is Rockplayer actually legit - Google seem to have suspended some versions of it for some reason. Is it safe to buy the full version?

 

[InfernalByte]

Rock player (free) on the market gave me no lag when I used it.

 

[Casual Pete]

I use mVideoplayer works fine for my needs.

mVideoPlayer - Android app on AppBrain


I wouldn't get too strung up on the class speed of your mem card either,most decent cards perform faster than the class ratings anyway,I've had no probs with my class 2.And I guess when playing movies it's the read speed that's important not the write so it's irrelevant what write speed it has.

 

[Rastaman-FB]

thats good, theres also vplayer alpha

 

[deeps86]

philips go gear connect will meet your requirements...

 

[Rastaman-FB]

? lol

 

[SUroot]

I've actually taken to printing the frames of a movie out onto paper and making a flip-book whilst adding my own dialogue and explosion sounds. It skips from time to time but the audio remains constant.

 

[rowlers]

I've actually taken to printing the frames of a movie out onto paper and making a flip-book whilst adding my own dialogue and explosion sounds. It skips from time to time but the audio remains constant.

I used to use rockplayer (paid for it!), now use moboplayer, its free and performs better.