Okay, There was a thread on this, but it was merged into the massive accessories thread, which I think was a bad move (But I won't get into that). I just got my nexus one sleeve in from FedEx about 5 minutes ago so I am here posting what I think. 1) The incredible (no case) fits fine in the sleeve. It slips in easy, but if you hold it upside down and shake it, the phone slowly slips out until about the 10th shake, and then it falls out. (But who will be holding it upside down and shaking it like a baby). 2) The incredible (with hard plastic gradient snap on case) will fit into the sleeve with some pushing and stretching. The issue is, You are not going to be able to get the phone out in a hurry to answer a phone call. The first time I put my Inc in the sleeve it took me about 20-30 seconds to get it out. Maybe that was because I was afraid of damaging the phone by pulling from the top and squeezing the bottom of the sleeve like a tube of toothpaste. 3) With the hard case on the Inc and the Inc in the sleeve the top corners of the phone sticks out slightly (maybe a few centimeters). So if you drop it and it lands just right (or wrong) it will hit the hard plastic case. But that is what the case is there for, right??? I will take and post some photos if I get any requests.