Rogers blocking SIP over 3G


Last Updated: 2012-01-27 14:14:28
  1. vikingisson

    vikingisson Well-Known Member

    I'm trying out the Sipdroid voip client on the Magic and it works nicely over WiFI but is blocked by Rogers over the cell connection. I verified that they are blocking things such as SIP and SSH. Not yet sure if I could run it on an alternate port but found that if I tether my laptop (via PDANet over USB) I can run x-lite over 3G but I couldn't check the port connection on my PBX since SSH is blocked...

    Anyone doing SIP on Android over the Rogers cell network?

    Advertisement
  2. vikingisson

    vikingisson Well-Known Member

    Well there is hope after all. If you download the devel version of Sipdroid you can select an alternate port such as 5061 it will register over 3G. Only issue now is being able to select which line to use, Sipdroid only allows SIP or phone as a preference, not on a per call or contact basis. But it works even with Rogers playing hard to get..
  3. JackTheMan18

    JackTheMan18 Well-Known Member

    I was testing SIPDROID on my HTC magic (I'm on FIDO).
    Now I know why I could never get it to work on the 3G!

    Thanks!
  4. vikingisson

    vikingisson Well-Known Member

    Glad to help. I'm brand new to Android and even cell phones in general. and I'm old-ish..

    Playing with this for a while I found it nice that it will register over WiFI if it can or 3G when not on WiFI. So you can always keep a connection. I paid the 1 Euro to get better audio quality. However there is one concern right now, it re-registers frequently which will eat the battery if on 3G.

    Until I get time to work on the power drain I don't keep it running all the time. Back at the PBX I set my extension to also ring my cell # for inbound calls. I then use SIP for LD outbound or when I want to talk to the PBX or another user on it. It will save me money without missing any calls or killing the battery. Nice compromise for now.
  5. sixpack

    sixpack Active Member

    Thanks for this, couldn't figure out what I was doing wrong with the 3g sip. I have found that so far using the Sipdroid was a pain because I allways had to manually enter the phone number into Sipdroid. Then I found on the Sipdroid website how to change the prefix on the fly. Automatically having the prefix added (I use a 001 prefix) while using Sipdroid had made my day. FAQ - sipdroid - Frequently Asked Questions - Project Hosting on Google Code The call quality is awesome too!
  6. vikingisson

    vikingisson Well-Known Member

    Thanks for the FAQ link. That helped with my questions, suddenly sipdroid seems even more promising. very 'linuxy'
  7. Miss_Almie112

    Miss_Almie112 Active Member

    Soo then this SIPDROID is a voip program that we can use on the magic? Does using this end up draining the battery faster?
  8. JackTheMan18

    JackTheMan18 Well-Known Member

    Battery drain is a real issue on the HTC Magic.
    This is how I have addressed it:
    1. I've purchased an extra 2 batteries - from ebay they are cheap and some have free shipping. (I never leave home without one!)
    2. I've purchased (also on ebay) a stand up charger - it charges a spare battery at the same time as it charges your Magic. Also, the Magic is in a holder, so that you can use it on your desk as a sort of desk unit.
    3. get advanced task killer from the market, and use it occasionally. You will find that the messaging app is always on and active. (I think that's a bug.) You will also find that your Magic is much faster after you have killed all those apps that are running.

    SIPDROID does work. If you get SIP credentials from freephoneline.ca, you will be able to use it without it counting to your cell phone minutes.
  9. sixpack

    sixpack Active Member

    Well since I only use Sipdroid while on a WiFi connection it doesn't drain the battery any faster than the WiFi does. As far as I can tell anyways.

    freephoneline looks like a great service thanks for the link, might have to try it out. I currently use an SIP account with mywebcalls in conjunction with pbxes
  10. vikingisson

    vikingisson Well-Known Member

    I've changed strategies a bit too. My PBX simul rings my cell number so I don't miss a call when not on WiFI. I usually only SIP over WiFI to save the battery. If I really need to make a call over SIP/3G I'll start the app. Best of all worlds.
  11. Miss_Almie112

    Miss_Almie112 Active Member

    So all in all, the best way to use this app would be to use over WiFI to save battery life? I'm new to this VOIP program and I am trying to register an SIP to use the app. I've gone to freephoneline.ca to register and now on my magic I am looking at how to set up through menu. Would anyone be able to point out how to set it up on the Rogers network? Thanks so much!
  12. vikingisson

    vikingisson Well-Known Member

    Do you have it working over WiFI? I don't know freephonline.ca but those freebie sites are usually a pain if they work at all with standard SIP apps. I prefer an "asterisk" friendly provider and then use any app I want including sipdroid. For the $5-$10/mth I spend which is primarily for the "real" phone number and pennies for actual calls I don't have to fuss around. Between a SIP deskphone, x-lite on the laptop, my Nokia N800, and now the Magic, I can make and take calls anytime, anywhere.
    Once you have it working over WiFI it should just work on Rogers if you grab the devel version as noted earlier in the thread.
  13. Miss_Almie112

    Miss_Almie112 Active Member

    Now is the devel version in the marketplace? Or would I have to get this from somewhere else? So then what would you suggest as a better SIP? From pbxes?
  14. Andy2010

    Andy2010 Well-Known Member

    I've tested Sipdroid with my 3G and it works. I don't think Rogers is blocking it.
  15. vikingisson

    vikingisson Well-Known Member

    yeah, not anymore they aren't. Mine now works on standard ports. A port check used to show UDP 5060 as blocked but now it doesn't. The new version of sipdroid is much easier on the battery BTW, older used to reregister much too frequently.
  16. Nacos

    Nacos New Member

    I have tried several SIP providers over CSipSimple but none proved reliable (not even close), so I went back on using fring. Although far from perfect it works reliably over both WiFi and 3G. Also their international rates are the most competitive comparing to Nimbuzz or Skype (by far the highest). Another advantage of fring is the ability of shutting it off completely once no longer needed (which means that the service doesn't run in the background nor it auto starts (configured in settings)) - which saves battery. I find it to be a better alternative to any available SIP/VoIP services. Anyone here has had a different experience?
  17. vikingisson

    vikingisson Well-Known Member

    A lot has changed in the years since this post was last updated. Thanks but no thanks on the Fring. Real SIP working just fine these days.

Share This Page