I purchased the Innocase active with the Incredible while I was on leave, but had the Speck cover been available, I would have strongly considered it. Heck, I don't even mind paying the $23 (discount) for the Speck when I get home, if it offers the convenience I'm looking for. I'm mainly looking for opinions from those who have used both cases, but if you only have an opinion on one, it's the Speck I want to know about. The Seidio was ideal for me as it offered the inner soft shell with the harder skeleton. It offers the ideal protection and I don't mind the added bulk at all. However, I need to remove it when changing the battery (every 1-2 days), and when putting it in the car mount as a GPS/hands free device. Peeling two layers and putting them back on gets old real fast, but it's something I expected and I'm more than ok with it. The Speck seems to advertise itself as being similar to the Active (soft inner shell, hard outer shell, melts in your mouth, not your hands), but is one piece rather than two. I don't care about the different in looks, as they each have their strong points. I'm concerned only with two things; 1) How easily does it go on and come off? Is it so easy you could do it with one hand while not even looking? That would be ideal. 2) How is the added bulk relative to the Innocase Active? Pictures below for those who want to know what I'm referencing (Speck is first, Innocase Active is 2nd).