Is there any way to sell my $25 plan, but keep my number?
No, your number is tied to your account. Once the number is ported the account is closed.
Just thought of this. What if I got the cheapest PayLo plan. I could and swapped the numbers, returned the phone, and then ported my number. I think that would then leave me with my $25 plan on a different number ready to sell.
Once the number from the $25 a month account is removed the account is closed regardless of how it is done.
Separate names with a comma.