Time-traveller caught on film using a cell phone in the '20s?

[Kabob]

Must have needed to go back to a time when the iPhone was superior...

 

[dan330]

I'd change three of these.

which is more interesting: 2
which is more scary: 3
which do I hope it is: 2

time travel is the more scary option.. if you think what that means in the big picture of the universe. the power it posses.. for those that want to abuse it.

what it means to free will.. if you can travel to the future..
what it means to everything.. if you can go back and mess things up... in so many ways...

 

[Storm613]

I don't see an object in her hand.. I think she's just fixing her hat or playing with her hair. Perhaps she is just chewing gum (Did they have that in 1928?) that makes it look like she's talking.

Also, think about it:

Who would she be talking to? how would she get service?

 

[Musky]

I don't see an object in her hand.. I think she's just fixing her hat or playing with her hair. Perhaps she is just chewing gum (Did they have that in 1928?) that makes it look like she's talking.

Also, think about it:

Who would she be talking to? how would she get service?

Well, one could argue that if she has the technology to travel back in time, she may not need cell towers or a network to communicate with "others of her kind".

 

[LOL DROID]

Hai guize, it's was me. I'm back now though.

 

[Chidori602]

This video is pretty cool, even if it's not what it seems to be .

Time traveler using cell phone captured in 1928 video of Chaplin premiere? - Phone Arena

you saw it on raywilliamjohnson didnt you?

 

[pantlesspenguin]

you saw it on raywilliamjohnson didnt you?

No someone in another cell phone forum I frequent posted it.

 

[Musky]

No someone in another cell phone forum I frequent posted it.

It's also been on the major news sites like CNN and Fox.

 

[If_Only_VZW_had_iPhones]

The device she was using could well have been one of these. Siemens Hearing Instruments - Our History 'Siemens patent for a compact, pocket sized carbon microphone/amplifier device suitable for pocket instruments.' ...patented in 1924.

...looks familiar.

As for who she was talking to. I would say either the guy walking in front of her or the zebra with the saddle.

If it was a time travelled mobile phone, she would definitely be talking to herself, there been no mobile networks in 1928.

yep - seems like this is the answer... but of course, notice how after this response was given, people ignored it opting for the extra-terrestrial, or time travel options. This is how rumors and conspiracy theories about places like Area 51 and the JFK assassination get started. Sometimes the truth is just so boring people don't want to believe it

 

[dan330]

yep - seems like this is the answer... but of course, notice how after this response was given, people ignored it opting for the extra-terrestrial, or time travel options. This is how rumors and conspiracy theories about places like Area 51 and the JFK assassination get started. Sometimes the truth is just so boring people don't want to believe it

i saw it...just not the most enjoyable option to talk about!

but what is she using it for during walking?
who is she talking to..using a hearing aid?

so if it is a hearing aid...and she is talking to it.. using up the batteries... then it is my option (1)..crazy woman

 

[TheBeardedMann]

If you don't know about this, watch this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y6a4T2tJaSU

And here's the "explanation" for it:
Charlie Chaplin Time Traveler's Cell Phone is a Siemens 1924 Hearing Aid | USA Live Headlines

 

[dan330]

old post

 

[Exiled]

As someone said before, if you have the technology to travel back in time, you would also have the technology to talk to people back where you came from.

So some say that Chaplin did this joke on purpose. I don't doubt for a second that Chaplin would pull this sort of gag (anyone seen Modern Times?). But I don't think a random lady walking in the background holding a box to her head and talking to herself is the best way to trick a future audience into thinking they see time travelers. (this is assuming Chaplin knowingly did this as a gag). I think he would do something a little more impressive or obvious than that. Now if it was some random lady from the future walking on to a set that was likely guarded by security (given Chaplin's fame, I would assume there was security of some sort), I think that is just as unlikely.

 

[baillou2]

It's also been on the major news sites like CNN and Fox.

Sad and pathetic that this would make the news. Nice to see fox and CNN so on the ball about the important issues of our day, and not concerning themselves with ridiculous crackpot notions.

Come to think of it, that's what they've always done.

 

[Musky]

Sad and pathetic that this would make the news. Nice to see fox and CNN so on the ball about the important issues of our day, and not concerning themselves with ridiculous crackpot notions.

Come to think of it, that's what they've always done.

I agree! But seeing how many posted in this thread and seeing how there were at least two threads started about it, I guess they're reporting what people want to hear. Maybe everyone was as sick of the political ads as I was. LOL