That's the pouch I have and I like it a lot. If you notice the case I got, with that case on the phone it fits pretty snug. It is loosing up a little over time. That case is pretty thin. My point being, if you have a big, thick bulky case, then the phone will really fit tight in that pouch. It has elastic in the sides and will stretch, but I personally wouldn't use that pouch on phones with large, thick cases. From the looks of the Body Glove case - I imagine it fill work fine as it does not look too bulky (I may get a Body Glove). Hope that helps.