• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Outrage, Slap in the face. Engadget says GPS bug is fixed by turning on "use wireless networks"

Did Chris Ziegler and Engadget get this totally wrong?


  • Total voters
    21
  • Poll closed .

SamsungVibrant

Android Expert
Jul 23, 2010
1,613
165
Am I reading this correctly, are my eyes really seeing what I think their seeing? Please read below, and if you agree with me, email Engadget and Chris (chris@engadget.com) asking them to further investigate their statements.
So here is the ordeal.

We all thought Engadget was smarter than this. What a complete embarassment for them.

Vibrant and Captivate owners a week ago found triumph when Engadget, a major tech site, put Samsung on the heating block and asked them where is the GPS fix? Oddly enough Chris Ziegler was the same person to pose this question to Samsung. Remember: http://mobile.engadget.com/2010/08/02/wheres-the-gps-fix-for-the-samsung-vibrant-and-captivate/

Well things have taken a 180 degree turn. Seems like senior editor Chris Ziegler needs to consider going into a new profession, because reviewing Android phones is way over his head.

Chris Ziegler reviewed the new Sprint Samsung Galaxy S Epic 4G, where he talked about the GPS bug. Shortly after his initial review, Samsung contacted Chris, and either Chris is really ammature, or Samsung pulled a big one over his head. This is what Chris has to say about the GPS bug:

"[Update: We just spoke with Samsung, who told us that Google is now requiring that the "use wireless networks" setting for location-based services be turned off by default in Android devices -- in other words, no AGPS unless you manually enable it. Sure enough, we went into Settings, found that it was disabled on the Epic, turned it on, and we were good to go. No GPS bug!]"

No GPS bug! ???????????? Are you nuts Chris? You really think people who own the Samsung Galaxy S phones haven't already tried turning this on. Boy did this editor get one pulled over his head. Turning on "use wireless networks" is nothing more than a mask, a cover up, a disguise to the real GPS bug.

I have many questions, my mind is in confusion, how could Engadget make such a mistake. Unless the Epic 4G is in a special category, maybe the Epic 4G doesn't have GPS problems. If this is the case, my next question would be, why do the Captivate and Vibrant have GPS problems and the Epic doesn't? I doubt the Epic has different GPS hardware than the Captivate or the Vibrant. I think the answer to this question is simple, Chris Ziegler f*cked up big time, thinking the resolution to the GPS problem is as simple as turning on "use wireless networks," something that is nothing more than a mask to the true GPS whoes. Something that many of us already have tried to no avail!

Article Below:

Epic 4G review -- Engadget

Please email Engadget, and ask them to Clarify what Chris meant by his statements. Is he stating that only Epic 4G has no GPS problems? Or is he stating all Galaxy S Phone GPS bugs can be eliminated by turning on "use wireless networks." Frankly, if the EPIC 4G has no GPS problems, Samsung better explain why the Captivate and Vibrant do.

UPDATE:
It appears Chris and Engadget heard our emails, and released the following: Now they say the there are 2 problems, not 1!
http://www.engadget.com/2010/08/17/samsung-galaxy-s-gps-gate-two-problems-not-one-and-what-to-do/
 
Looks like the "fix" is in, alright. Engadget aren't the only ones spinning this new line.

I called AT&T today to have them put it on the record that my GPS is defective, so that down the line if Samsung never fixes it, I have some leverage. Well no sooner than I mention GPS and the tech says, Hey! We have an official fix for your issue! I said, Oh really! And I was told that the "official fix" was... enable "Use Wireless Networks." I explained this was not a fix but a coverup and asked to be escalated. I was told by the manager that Corp instructed them today that this is the official fix to the problem. I inquired as to whether it would be really fixed, for real, and was told that "this is the fix" and that the matter had been resolved.

I wonder what's going on here? String people along just enough until the return window is over? Did Samsung put AT&T up to this or where is this concerted effort coming from all of a sudden?

All I can do is stand in wonderment at how conveniently they come up with this new line of bull right at the 30 day mark, eh!
 
Upvote 0
Looks like the "fix" is in, alright. Engadget aren't the only ones spinning this new line.

I wonder what's going on here? String people along just enough until the return window is over? Did Samsung put AT&T up to this or where is this concerted effort coming from all of a sudden?

All I can do is stand in wonderment at how conveniently they come up with this new line of bull right at the 30 day mark, eh!


Please email engadget with your concerns, if a major tech site says something like this, we will never get a GPS fix.
 
Upvote 0
there are no wireless networks to help me navigate in the middle of nowhere.

please call at&t and report this. As most companies, they code tickets and calls. There are people that actually collect this data and its used to present to manufactures or developers for issues, such as the gps issue.

I still think that part of the gps issue is att. since they got to mod the os to their liking too, things got messed up. samsung and att need to work together on this and get it fixed properly.
 
Upvote 0
part of the issue, not just att, but any carrier. they all mod the crap out of OS's on phones. There is an issue with it from the factory though.

True carriers mod phones, but in this case, the samsung galaxy S is a world phone, and has gone to several carriers around the world, they all have problems. So I would say finger points towards samsung.

I think samsung is also probably pissed off at google for requiring that "use wireless networks" to be default set to off. I imagine samsung is thinking "shit, if these phones shipped with this set on, then maybe we coulda had this problem hidden for a while." sadly, even with that on, the navigation still performs poorly
 
Upvote 0

BEST TECH IN 2023

We've been tracking upcoming products and ranking the best tech since 2007. Thanks for trusting our opinion: we get rewarded through affiliate links that earn us a commission and we invite you to learn more about us.

Smartphones