1. My phone is my iPod
2. Everything else syncs too
3. Apps
4. Games
5. Details, details, details
Having used an iPhone for six months and now Android for a couple of weeks, my take on this:
1. Many people like the sync between iPhone and iTunes. Personally, I don't - I like the control I have over what and when I copy music over. But a LOT of people like the fact that new music in iTunes is automatically sync'd to their iPhone. They like the fact that playlists are sync'd, etc.
2. iPhone sync's photos, videos, etc with the desktop. Calendar, contacts, etc, all sync too. Yes, Android syncs with Google, but that is a pain to sync with my desktop. I have just about given up on having good contact sync between my desktop and my phone right now.
3. Apps. Yes Android has apps. Lots of them. But iPhone has more and they are BETTER. There's no doubt in my mind that iPhone apps are more polished, more finished, and available to ALL iPhone users. I can't buy any protected apps from the Market. I don't know why and I don't know who to get to fix it.
4. Games. I think everyone can see that games on the iPhone are FAR better than games on Android right now. Granted, it may not always be the case, but right now they are. And unless Google sort out the mess that is the Market, people will either not be able to buy the games, or (like me on 1.5) not be able to see screen shots, etc, and therefore not want to buy them. Developers will then not carry on developing.
5. I'll give this one to Android - details on iPhone are great...everything is polished, works and looks good. But that IS at the expense of user configuration and freedom to DO more with their phones.
It's quite obvious that, this being an Android forum, everyone is going to rubbish this, but I am VERY disapointed with my Android experience so far and am worried about the choice I have made.