First- I have to admit I skipped most of this thread after the first page.
Now....
My best assessment of the Android OS-- It's a perfect cross between a Windows phone and an iPhone.
Think about it. The A. OS allows customization out of the box (without roms etc) just like the Windows M. phones, while at the same time offering the features and overall stability of an iPhone.
It's really genius and I believe that eventually the iPhone will loose significant market share to the Android phones. (I've owned iPhone since day one, and I just made my switch to Android for the second time.. first time is a long story and i ended up with BB)
I still own a 3rd gen iPod touch. Love it.... use it in the gym every day, use it at night when I can't sleep. It's my main media device.
I like to have a phone and a music player separate with a little bit of cross functionality if needed on the phone side.
Sure there will always be a place for the iPhones, they're simple to use and any monkey can make one work the way they want.
Give that monkey an Android based phone and they can make it work, but they would not have a clue on how to make it work even better.
That's what I love about the Android- I can tinker with it and make it work like I WANT it to work and still have a great phone, yet not be locked down to one email program.
C'mon.... until iOS4 you couldn't even make folders or custom wallpapers! Files and folders?? I'm an iPhone, what does that mean?
Someone said earlier.... different strokes for different folks.
The iPhone's here to stay, but it has and will loose market share to the Android based phones.
***Disclaimer*** This was based off of the average consumer who doesn't know what rooting a phone, rom, or jail break means.