I have had my EVO for about a week now and am a long time iPhone user. I have had all the iPhones except for the iPhone 4. I have also evaluated the Nexus One, The Galaxy S Captivate, the Droid X and now I'm evaluating the EVO.
I'm not trying to be overly negative with this comparison, and some of what I consider negatives with the EVO are also present on the other Android phones I've tried out.
I don't consider the Android way of doing things different from the iPhone way of doing things a negative, just something I need to learn how to do. The same would hold true for someone coming from any other phone to Android for the first time.
The negatives I list here were copied from a earlier post because the are exactly the same things I dislike (I find them to be the same for all Android phones)
Negatives:
- Android apps are generally not nearly as polished, or full featured overall
- Games are not as good as iPhone's (e.g. Angry Birds, Bejeweled Blitz)
- Android OS -- even with Sense -- doesn't feel as polished as iPhone OS
- Lack of good backup/restore options without rooting (I don't really want to root my phone just for backup and I've already paid for tethering anyway)
- Nowhere near the number of accessories as the iPhone
- Battery life -- I should of said lack of battery life. Not very good for me so far
Positives:
- The screen -- Gotta love it, makes the iPhone look like a toy
- 4G Speed -- The EVO on 4G is amazing. I don't have 4G at home, but I do have it at work.
- Widgets -- I really like them
- Multi-tasking - The way it should work
Now if I could find headphones with inline music controls that allow me to change volume, switch tracks.
There are a few apps I have on my iPhone that I have not installed on the EVO just yet, mainly because they're expensive (Slingbox App) and I am not sure if I'll keep the EVO yet.
I did find the Angry Birds app (still in beta), and bought the regular version of Bejeweled. The Android version is not as smooth to play, there seems to be some lag when moving jewels.
Overall I'm very impressed with the EVO, more than I was with the other Android phones I've evaluated. That 4G speed can make the negatives seem not that important. Now I just need to get the headphone/earbud ith inline music controls thing figured out.