Well I guess I will go find a cheap temporary case for now, just cancelled my Amazon order. I'm not paying $50 for a case for it to not fit right or snap close right. It wasn't going to ship till nearly Thanksgiving anyway.
I'm just going to order straight from Otterbox after they get these issues fixed.
michaelkahl, check to make sure that a tab that hold the polycarbonate shell together hasn't snapped off. I am currently dealing with this problem on the Defender I have on my iPod. It looks like there was a defect in the plastic and I guess the last time I opened the case a tab broke off. Now the lower left corner won't stay together unless the silicone is on. But I have emailed Otterbox about this and they said if I send them pics of the break along with my address I should get a new case under warranty.