• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

My Desire, and why I'm keeping it.

williamj1

Android Enthusiast
Sep 11, 2010
641
214
UK
Over the last few weeks, I've seen an increasing amount of threads about people upgrading, or moving on to something new. I thought I'd share my thoughts on why I'm keeping mine.

First of all, the issues that I once had with my Desire have all been solved. Possibly the biggest problem was internal memory. Now sure, it isn't fixed like on a new handset with 1GB ROM, but I wouldn't ever use all that. And now with the likes of Alpharev and Data2Ext, I can do this.

The camera: This is possibly the one area new phones excel. But to be honest, I don't use it all that often and I recently took out the rear lens cover, which has made a world of difference.

Android is a platform that is no longer just for us geeks. There are increasing numbers of lower price models for sale. There may be dual core handsets, but other than the general speed of the phone, they offer few other advantages at this point. Pretty much all the games on the market, iPlayer, Flash 10.2 etc - they all work perfectly on the Desire. And that is something I don't think will change for a while. I think 1ghz will stay normal for the time being.

We have the latest OS. I'm running CM7 just now, and it's just one of the many 2.3.3 based ROMS available for the Desire. Last night, 2.3.4 was pushed out for the Nexus S. Already, a dev on XDA has ported it to the Desire. What's more, HTC continue to support us and will soon push out an official 2.3.x Desire update OTA.

And this leads me nicely onto another point: The Desire community is still very much alive. Dev's continue to support it with a huge selection of ROMS and MOD's. I would even go as far as saying they do so more than on the newer devices. The community is, and remains, quite remarkable.

If there is one gripe I have about my Desire, it's the apps and games available on the market. I really do wish there were much more better quality apps (dare I say iOS standard). I really think this is the biggest problem with Android, and as soon as it achieves this, Apple will be far less of a competitor. But, this is very much an Android problem. A new device will not fix this.

Now don't get me wrong, if I was offered a free HTC Sensation or Galaxy S2, I would drop my Desire in a heartbeat. But I wouldn't be doing so without sacrifice. I would lose my physical buttons and my optical trackpad, the thriving dev community and not least, my ability to root - It is without doubt, the original,greatest, Android phone.

It hasn't lost support, and it hasn't fallen behind the others. I don't really need to upgrade. I don't really want to upgrade. It's not lost the battle just yet.

My Desire is staying. For the time being at least.

Frost_HTC_Blue_Comp.jpg
 
Well I think I'll be jumping over to the Galaxy S II fairly soon.

3.7" has become too small for me. I need some 4.3" glory!

Even with A2SD+, I still sometimes have problems with storage.

Multi-touch on the Desire is awful! Especially for gaming.

Speed is never really an issue with CM7, but something about a duel core 1.2 Ghz processor in my phone that is faster than the one in my laptop excites me hugely.

And yes, that probably means that I'm buying a new phone out of pure geekyness rather than practicality, but that's who I am. And I guess these super specs make the phone quite future proof as well.

Also, I am tired of my phone's screen getting beaten by iPhone 4's! SAMOLED+ should solve that problem!

The way I see it, is that the next big jump in specs (Duel core 2Ghz processors and 5" HHD displays or whatever) will not be for at least another year. See; last year our phone was announced at MWC 2010, and nothing really beat it's specs that badly until MWC/CES 2011. If things follow the same pattern this year then you will ether have to buy a Sensation or SGSII (Or one of the many copies cats that will inevitably be created ;P) when it's not quite so new and cool...

OR

You will have to wait another year for the next generation of better spec phones.

I would rather get these super-phone monsters while they're hot!

And there is also the rumored September iPhone key-note date to conciser. I think everyone is quite sure that Apple are going to try to beat or equal all the current competition with their iPhone 5. But the postponed release cycle means that if I get the SGSII now then will probably have around half a year to enjoy it before it has any real non-Android competition. Quite an rare optionality actually.

This is all speculation by the way! :D

I totally see where you guys are coming from; it seems very materialistic to replace my phone annually. But, I'm kinda a geek, so, yeah.....
 
Upvote 0
I think this was well said and I am happy to hear that my Desire is not an old out of date phone. I love the updates and I say about 98% of the time apps just work on the Desire. I have not had to many problems with flashing my phone with new roms. There has been a few bugs but I think in the big picture other phones are having way more problems. I agree the internal memory was a disappointment but after rooting I have not had a problem.But with that being said I am looking at the Samsung being my next phone but that will not be for awhile so I will enjoy my Desire till then...
 
Upvote 0
I think this was well said and I am happy to hear that my Desire is not an old out of date phone. I love the updates and I say about 98% of the time apps just work on the Desire. I have not had to many problems with flashing my phone with new roms. There has been a few bugs but I think in the big picture other phones are having way more problems. I agree the internal memory was a disappointment but after rooting I have not had a problem.But with that being said I am looking at the Samsung being my next phone but that will not be for awhile so I will enjoy my Desire till then...

+1. GS2 or Sensation look to be my next phone, but not for a few months yet. Unless I win the lottery of course ;)
 
Upvote 0
Over the last few weeks, I've seen an increasing amount of threads about people upgrading, or moving on to something new. I thought I'd share my thoughts on why I'm keeping mine.

First of all, the issues that I once had with my Desire have all been solved. Possibly the biggest problem was internal memory. Now sure, it isn't fixed like on a new handset with 1GB ROM, but I wouldn't ever use all that. And now with the likes of Alpharev and Data2Ext, I can do this.

The camera: This is possibly the one area new phones excel. But to be honest, I don't use it all that often and I recently took out the rear lens cover, which has made a world of difference.

Android is a platform that is no longer just for us geeks. There are increasing numbers of lower price models for sale. There may be dual core handsets, but other than the general speed of the phone, they offer few other advantages at this point. Pretty much all the games on the market, iPlayer, Flash 10.2 etc - they all work perfectly on the Desire. And that is something I don't think will change for a while. I think 1ghz will stay normal for the time being.

We have the latest OS. I'm running CM7 just now, and it's just one of the many 2.3.3 based ROMS available for the Desire. Last night, 2.3.4 was pushed out for the Nexus S. Already, a dev on XDA has ported it to the Desire. What's more, HTC continue to support us and will soon push out an official 2.3.x Desire update OTA.

And this leads me nicely onto another point: The Desire community is still very much alive. Dev's continue to support it with a huge selection of ROMS and MOD's. I would even go as far as saying they do so more than on the newer devices. The community is, and remains, quite remarkable.

If there is one gripe I have about my Desire, it's the apps and games available on the market. I really do wish there were much more better quality apps (dare I say iOS standard). I really think this is the biggest problem with Android, and as soon as it achieves this, Apple will be far less of a competitor. But, this is very much an Android problem. A new device will not fix this.

Now don't get me wrong, if I was offered a free HTC Sensation or Galaxy S2, I would drop my Desire in a heartbeat. But I wouldn't be doing so without sacrifice. I would lose my physical buttons and my optical trackpad, the thriving dev community and not least, my ability to root - It is without doubt, the original,greatest, Android phone.

It hasn't lost support, and it hasn't fallen behind the others. I don't really need to upgrade. I don't really want to upgrade. It's not lost the battle just yet.

My Desire is staying. For the time being at least.

Frost_HTC_Blue_Comp.jpg

I 100% agree - I couldn't of said it better myself!
- the biggest problem I would have with getting rid of my Desire is that I would loose the huge Dev community for the Desire as it's so popular and I will loose the ability to root. Im happy with it :)
 
Upvote 0
I'm interested to hear everyone's thoughts on the point I raised about the quality of apps and games

Coming from iOS before, that's how I feel. I was expecting a bit of a rebuttal on that though, as I hear lots saying the market is great...
I agree with you on that but I knew that when I got the phone.

The reason it didn't bother me is that I felt that the Android market would expand at an ever faster rate, and soon catch and probably overtake Apple when it comes to apps.

Games I feel is a bit uncertain because of fragmentation and the variety of hardware (look at Gameloft restricting games to certain phones) but this didn't/doesn't bother me as I'm not much of a gamer.
 
Upvote 0
The major issue in upgrading for me now is the inability to root and tinker, and the fact the latest phones dont really bring anything to the party.. yes they may be faster, have bigger screens and all that jazz, but it really doesnt do much for me.

As sad as it sounds I enjoy flashing a new rom every now and again, and adding odds and sods as and when different things are released, its become a sort of mini hobby :)

Maybe part of the appeal is having to learn all these different things as you go along, yes none of its hard and most things have great guides to walk you through but ive still learnt a hell of alot since first joining the world of android.

Maybe I have a rose tinted view as its my first 'smartphone' but i couldnt be happier with the complete package of the desire. For me, at this moment in time the desire does pretty much everything I want a phone to do. its just a good all round piece of kit, perfect size, its well built and feels like it could take some rough handling, not that in going to test it, the camera is fine for the odd snap, works fine as an mp3 player. satnav is great and the multitude of apps is a godsend... any little niggles ive had such as the memory issues have been sorted out by the talented people in the dev community.

Long may the desire community continue, itll be a sad sad day when it dies..
 
Upvote 0
Well the SGSII got root assess before it was even released.

No custom ROMS at the moment as far as I know, but I think a lot of devs will be getting this phone, so I'm sure there will be some soon.

But actually, as long as I can use my root apps, I don't think that I will really need a custom ROM. Toutchwiz is bearable.

And anyway, the main reasons I flashed CM7 was for speed and A2SD+, neither of which I will need to hack to get with the SGSII.
 
Upvote 0
Ive never had ios, but the quality of apps I have are great. Im coming from blackberry where there are few apps that are even interesting.

Android market, any app I need - theres something there for it.

I agree with you on the apps front. Any app I want there is something for it, and they tend to be pretty good. But the gaming just simply doesn't compare. There are some really amazing games on iOS. I'm considering emailing / nagging developers and asking them to port them over. I want a decent racing game (real racing (iOS) is soooo good) and a decent pinball game. Bigger games like angry birds, gameloft ones and doodle jump etc are finally being ported over, but they aren't all here yet. And I still have that stupid transaction fee!

I get the feeling if you could root the S or Sensation, you'd happily move along. ;)

I think the general consensus is that the Desire S isn't really a suitable upgrade. I feel that an "upgrade" should offer improved performance and lots of new features. But it has the same size screen, same 5mp camera, same ghz processor (I know it's 2nd gen but still). I don't think it really justifies all that money.

I think the sensation could be huge. If it is able to be rooted and so forth, and the dev community move over to it, I will happily switch. My only concern is that when the Desire came out, it was not only the best phone on the market, but also really quite affordable. Those two combined to create it's success. Now though, the sensation will likely be
 
Upvote 0
Will keeping mine until renewal time next, unless of course I come in to some money that I can freely squander on a new phone, and then again it would have to be a big upgrade.

I would like a bigger screen though, but that doesn't warrant getting a totally new phone when the Desire does everything I need it to do.
 
Upvote 0
Having taken ownership of a Desire HD and still having my previous Desire I can honestly tell you all in truth there is not a great deal your missing out on other than the SGS II and Sensation. I will also go on to say the only true benefit I think is standout on the DHD is its 1GB internal memory as I was fed up of clearing caches and removing apps to keep that b*****d low memory warning from appearing every 2 minutes.

I still get second thoughts about letting my original Desire go every time I hold it, it is so light compared to my DHD and the AMOLED screen is stunning (I don't buy the over saturated colours argument, its just jealousy with a tinge of regret) along with the ease of taking pictures with a physical button.

All in all if I wasn't such a big fan of the EVO for its looks and the fact that while the DHD colours are dull it comes cloesest to matching it and if the internal memory was the same on both units, I'd quite happily sell my DHD on.
 
Upvote 0

BEST TECH IN 2023

We've been tracking upcoming products and ranking the best tech since 2007. Thanks for trusting our opinion: we get rewarded through affiliate links that earn us a commission and we invite you to learn more about us.

Smartphones