• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Help HDMI Mirroring

Has anyone used the HDMI Mirroring to their TV? My television tells me that the audio output from the phone is in a bad format. It still plays sound from netflix and video is fine but the sound quality is poor with occasional crackles/hisses and some synchronization issues.

I believe the occasional crackling with Netflix over HDMI is a known issue. My wife and I both have this issue with our Bionics, and I've seen it mentioned in the forums as well. I can stream Google Music beta over HDMI with no crackling, and Netflix doesn't crackle when played through the phone speaker, so it seems to be a weird bug with just this combination (Netflix + HDMI). Not sure if we need a Netflix update to fix it or what. I also ordered a longer HDMI cable, so I can test that when it arrives to completely rule out a faulty cable.
 
Upvote 0
I don't get any crackling, but playing Netflix via HDMI mirroring is extremely choppy - too annoying to watch. When I watch Netflix straight from the phone I get excellent playback and quality.

As Somniferum says, "it seems to be a weird bug with just this combination (Netflix + HDMI)". I really hope they fix this issue as the Netflix option was a significant decision point in my purchase of the Bionic.
 
Upvote 0
I don't get any crackling, but playing Netflix via HDMI mirroring is extremely choppy - too annoying to watch. When I watch Netflix straight from the phone I get excellent playback and quality.

As Somniferum says, "it seems to be a weird bug with just this combination (Netflix + HDMI)". I really hope they fix this issue as the Netflix option was a significant decision point in my purchase of the Bionic.

I registered here just to quote this. My biggest gripe with this phone and HD dock.
I have a bunch of blue ray backups encoded at 720p and none of them play back for crap. All sorts of choppiness and it's not even viewable. Wouldn't you think a phone that records '1080p' could at least play back 720?
 
Upvote 0
It must be the TV. I connected to my "generic" brand LCD and everything works great. So I guess the lesson is high-end TV's suck for HDMI mirroring.

Netflix was still a bit choppy though. Streaming stuff from my computer using zumocast worked great.

No.

I've reproduced the same problem on my 'high-end' living room TV and my bedroom (not so high-end) TV.
 
Upvote 0
I registered here just to quote this. My biggest gripe with this phone and HD dock.
I have a bunch of blue ray backups encoded at 720p and none of them play back for crap. All sorts of choppiness and it's not even viewable. Wouldn't you think a phone that records '1080p' could at least play back 720?

I wonder if the app "Act 1 Video Player" would work for playback.

I know for a FACT, that the software "DVD Catalyst 4" can and will CONVERT videos that can play in HD on the Droid Bionic. It only cost me $10. Here is their website: http://www.tools4movies.com/
 
Upvote 0
I registered here just to quote this. My biggest gripe with this phone and HD dock.
I have a bunch of blue ray backups encoded at 720p and none of them play back for crap. All sorts of choppiness and it's not even viewable. Wouldn't you think a phone that records '1080p' could at least play back 720?

With most Android devices, its not that 720p is the limitation, but some of the advanced settings used to encode the video to H264. Things like the profile (main, baseline, high) as well as Cabac, Reference frames etc are not supported fully, so you end up with either unplayable files or stuttering playback. Of course, the audio format from your files is also a big factor. 5.1 audio is problematic, and will either result in hissing or no audio at all.

Players like Dice, Rock, Mobo can make those files play, however, because they use a software-based decoding engine, rather than the hardware, the processor speed as well as the optimizations used in their codecs become a major factor in playback as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DanDroide
Upvote 0
With most Android devices, its not that 720p is the limitation, but some of the advanced settings used to encode the video to H264. Things like the profile (main, baseline, high) as well as Cabac, Reference frames etc are not supported fully, so you end up with either unplayable files or stuttering playback. Of course, the audio format from your files is also a big factor. 5.1 audio is problematic, and will either result in hissing or no audio at all.

Players like Dice, Rock, Mobo can make those files play, however, because they use a software-based decoding engine, rather than the hardware, the processor speed as well as the optimizations used in their codecs become a major factor in playback as well.

Thank you, I was just mentioning your software and how it works well for me. I appreciate your educated opinion on this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dvdcatalyst
Upvote 0
Bitrate is probably an issue too. Not sure what the phone can handle for playback.

I am not sure about the Bionic, but on a Xoom I stopped at 20Mbps H264 (1080). On my Droid X and my NOOKcolor, I think I stopped at 5000Kbps. In all cases the video played back fluently, so I would expect the Bionic to be able to handle 5000 easily.

Edit:
The 1GHz TI OMAP 4430 seems to be in the Playbook as well, and on that I also managed to play a 1080 video at 20Mbps
 
  • Like
Reactions: DanDroide
Upvote 0

BEST TECH IN 2023

We've been tracking upcoming products and ranking the best tech since 2007. Thanks for trusting our opinion: we get rewarded through affiliate links that earn us a commission and we invite you to learn more about us.

Smartphones