I'm testing it out. I'm going back to my original home for thanksgiving so I can test out reception there.
It's good so far. Why exactly don't I want this phone? I really want to know why you think this phone is a bad choice. Right now, I'm just gonna go a month with it, and if it's good, i'm gonna switch.
This is the second time I've been through the "stress" about a phone. I know we do it to ourselves, but if I go with T-Mobile, I know they have a history of being much more open about these things.
At this rate, I might get ICS before you do anyway.
Couple of reasons, but before I get into specifics, I want to give you some insight with my experience.
A little phone was launched in Europe in 2010 called the Samsung Galaxy S. It was amazing for the time, and showed that Samsung could be taken seriously with an Android release. A couple of months go by and, out of nowhere, T-Mobile USA announces that they will be the first carrier to carry a US variant (called the Vibrant). This was exciting to me because I was, and am still right now, a T-Mobile customer, and at the time, my G1 was on its last legs. The phone came out 2 weeks earlier than anticipated release date in July, and not only that, T-Mobile had made it so that even though I was 6 months away from upgrading, I could take the upgrade price of 199 if I had signed a new contract.
Great, I thought. I picked up the phone on launch day. Now, the phone had launched with Eclair, but a week before the phone came out, both T-Mobile and SamsungUS had swore we would see the Froyo update within a month (Froyo had just launched a little earlier). There were obvious issues with the stock Eclair build, such as extreme lag, non-working GPS, and a problem sending MMS messages to contacts that weren't in the +1xxxxxxx format. No problem I thought, these would be fixed with an update.
Fast forward 5 months to December. We are still on Eclair, still with lag, still with the laggy filesystem, and still with the MMS problems. Just then we get the Froyo update, but not the REAL Froyo update. Samsung threw us a bone and gave us an update that was unfinished because all of us over at XDA caused a HUGE twitter stink to T-Mo/Samsung. By then, all of the other carriers had proper Froyo builds on there GS variants.
Another month and a half goes by and we finally get the official, T-Mobile endorsed 2.2 OS update. And yet we were still with the laggy filesystem, the MMS issues, and the broken GPS (a hardware failure that T-Mo/Samsung never officially admitted to or recalled). At this time, T-Mobile released an "updated" Vibrant, which they called the Samsung Galaxy S 4G. The only thing different about it was that it had HSPA+ radios and a front-facing camera. The "Vibrant" model was immediately EOL'ed, 6 and a half months in. I wish I could tell you there was a happy ending to that one, but the Vibrant never received another update to address the other issues. Just 2 days ago, the Galaxy S 4G got its Gingerbread update. The Vibrant still sits on firmware from January.
See, T-Mobile has always had this problem. They release a phone, hype it to high hell, call it their "flagship" device. And then in 5-6 months, they EOL it for something else, and then drop all support/updates for the device. It happened with every Windows Mobile device I've ever had from them, starting with the T-Mobile PocketPC Phone Edition I got in 2002, and continued up to the Vibrant, which I actually just sold for some extra money towards the GNex. I'm back on my G1 to tie me over until then.
Basically, T-Mo is a really shitty company when it comes to support and updates. They will lie to your face when it comes to any issues with your phone. They talked people out of returning their defective Vibrants with the GPS issues, saying that a software update would fix it. By the time everyone realized it was a hardware issue, it was too late to return.
So, aside from all of that, here is why you should stay away from the T-Mobile variant GS2:
1. Uses a completely different processor/hardware/chipset than all other GS variants. All of the other variants use the Exynos chipset, T-Mobiles variant has a Snapdragon. This will delay the update to ICS considerably and make it even harder or next to impossible for 3rd party ROMs that are based off of the international GS2 to be made. After the initial ICS update, don't expect any more updates for the life of the phone/life of your contract.
2. They increased the screen size to 4.52 inches while having the same resolution of 800x480. Basically, the res. on that size screen sucks.
3. There are issues with the screen itself. Either a hardware fault of the screen they used, or it isn't properly calibrated. Artifacts are seen and if you compare the screen to any other GS2 model, it will be apparent.
If you are going to get a GS2, please do it on either of the other two carriers. T-Mobiles' is just not worth it.