• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Root [Rom]Ice Cream Sandwich

Upvote 0
After running this for about a week in beta two, and a day in beta three, I think it's time for a basic review. At first glance this Rom is very nice. It's very fluid and the new features, such as the new browser, are cool.

You have an added widgets tab in the app drawer to add widgets to your desktop. So no more holding the homescreen to add widgets. This of course could be a drawback for those that are so used to holding the homescreen to add a widget.

I guess it would all come down to who is willing to get used to the new layout and who refuses to. You do have the option of using what's called "Nova Launcher" that will add the holding home for widgets feature back. System menus are also totaly revamped for ease of access.

From Running this Rom I can tell you it is a 2nd init Rom but also runs as though it was a stock 1st init Rom. It has the fluidity of a 2nd init but benchmarks as a 1st init. I'm assuming this is because the port isn't stable yet. It very well might outbenchmark other 2nd init Roms when it's complete.

Now on to the downsides to this Rom. One major drawback to this Rom, and other versions of it, is the camera. There is no source file to take the camera driver from so it has to be writen from the bottom up which is not an easy task. So for the time being the camera is non excistant.

ICS, or Android 4.0, was designed to work on the latest hardware and is not meant to run on the Droid X. I, among many others, am very excited to see this ported over to our DX's but our hardware leaves us with on fundimental flaw, power.

ICS being designed to run on a duel core processor with the latest GPU leaves us DX users at a disadvantage. So while ICS may, in time, be 100% successfully ported over to the DX it will never live up to it's full potential.

In my honest opinion, ICS would be better suited to be ported over to at least the Droid X2 as it has the better hardware and potential to run it. This of course is assuming the X2 won't get ICS in the near future.

So there you have it. A very basic review of this Rom. This isn't meant to scare anyone away from at least trying it out. That option is soley up to you. Just keep in mind that it is STILL beta. So there are many glitches still to be attended to.

Feel free to check out the link for beta 3 to see what these glitches are as SOME of them have workarounds. I actualy love this Rom and can't wait for it to be complete. Even with the hardware drawbacks this Rom runs faster than any 2nd init Rom I have ever used.
 
Upvote 0
The only lingering issue I can see with this ROM is the camera. I feel the DX is more than powerful enough to run ICS, my phone has no or very little lag issues at all. It runs far smoother than Gingerbread did on my phone, and that's saying quite a bit. Now while I haven't used ICS on something like the Nexus, I don't feel like our phones are limiting it at all, so the user experience is still intact at least.

I didn't like the Trebuchet or Nova though, so I'm sticking with Go Launcher on this one. Good news for those who prefer it, because it works just fine.

I agree with the rest of it though. This definitely feels better than CM7/CM7GB for sure.
 
Upvote 0
I ve been using this rom for 2 days now its nice smooth and pretty fast. Biggest problems im seeing beside the camera is lack of flash and sometimes scrolling can be a little laggy. The battety life has been ok with heavy use not the greatest but ok. Ive always noticed that the multi tasking takes a good couple of seconds to react which gets annoying. But with all that being said this rom is only a couple weeks old so give it time. Cant wait for firstEncounter final build its gonna be beastly.
 
Upvote 0
Been running beta3 for two days. It's pretty smooth though I feel it's not as fluid as Miui 1.12.9. The ICS UI is not as polished as I expected but it's very refreshing and somehow deeply satisfying. The ROM itself is quite stable for a beta. I haven't run into any major problem other than the known ones (camera and voice input). The camera is a deal breaker for this to be a long term daily driver but for the time being I'm loving it.

Oh, battery life for me is about the same as other 2-init ROM I tried. It barely gets through a day of heavy use, which is not great but good enough.
 
Upvote 0
I flashed it last night and my phone went way past stupid so I tried to just use my back up and it wouldn't do and when it did I was stuck on my boot loader image I left it for about an hour and it never loaded up so I had to sbf when that didn't fix it I had to change my sd card,sbf,reroot and now my phone is working fine but I don't think I will flash ics again until its all buged out
 
Upvote 0

BEST TECH IN 2023

We've been tracking upcoming products and ranking the best tech since 2007. Thanks for trusting our opinion: we get rewarded through affiliate links that earn us a commission and we invite you to learn more about us.

Smartphones