• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

iPhone 4 -> G Nex -> SGS2 -> iPhone 4s - BATTERY?

tawheed

Newbie
Jan 17, 2012
19
1
Alright, here's the story..

I was RIM guy til the iPhone 3G was launched in Canada. Bought one on day one and never looked back. Picked up the 4 soon after it came out and was extremely satisfied with it.. Last year, I sold the 4 out of boredom and picked up a Nexus S. It was a neat phone but the terrible battery life (vs the iPhone) and generally worse display made me end up selling it and buying another iPhone 4..

When the GNEX launched here I became interested and went and picked one up. I was BLOWN away by how much more refined ICS is, I was also very impressed with the screen clarity (ppi much closer to iPhone) but the battery issue still existed.. whereas no matter how much I messed with my iPhone during the day I'd never have to charge until I decided to go to sleep (could be 2-3am). For this reason (and this reason alone) I decided to go back to the practicality of my iPhone and give up the beauty of android / ICS.

Someone then mentioned to me the SGSII would be a good solution to my dilemma. I picked one up and gingerbread seemed extremely antiquated so that experiment lasted three days.

I figured if I'm going to use an iPhone anyway may as well get the 4s, so picked one up and sold my 4. Here's the kicker.. 4S BATTERY IS TERRIBLE!!!! No where near as good as my 4 was! Doesn't look to be any solution in site so now I'm thinking if I have to deal with crappy battery life why not just get a Gnex again?

Now on to the questions:

I'm interested in custom roms etc but have never kept an android device long enough to exploit such ideas - my home PC is also a Mac so I'm wondering how much of a pain it is to do such things on a mac vs a windows based machine

Second, I've read about people using juice defender or under clocking their Gnex CPU to really drag out the battery life - how difficult is this? If the battery life on the Gnex could be improved it would definitely be my phone of choice.

Anyway, sorry for the long post (rant) but I'd like some opinions / advice on the Gnex battery so I can make an educated decision (and not buy and sell three more phones)

Thanks
 
Did you update your 4s to 5.0.1? It solved the battery issue. I'm a heavy user and my 4s gets me thru a 12hr day with 30% to spare. Different story on the gnex. Just carry a spare battery. It'll save you the trouble of rooting especially on a Mac.

Yes, I'm on 5.0.1. Battery still doesn't seem nearly as good as it did on my iPhone 4. For a device that isn't significantly better I'm disappointed at how much worse the battery is.
 
Upvote 0
It does have a dual core and better camera/video...you're an impatient guy...5.1 is just around the corner...why not wait instead of blowing more money? GN with big arse screen and dual core, battery life will be worst than 4s, no matter what app you're using to conserve battery. You buy Android for the power, customization, and big screen...you do NOT buy it because it has long battery life!
 
Upvote 0
My stock Nexus would get me through a whole day without charging. About 11:00pm, I'd usually be around 10-15%.

Ever since I started using LeanKernel, though, I am regularly plugging the phone in at night when it's around 30% or higher.

Incidentally, I owned an iPhone 3G and 3GS so I have some basis for comparison to the iPhone. I get roughly equivalent battery life to either the 3G or 3GS.

Replacing the kernel is pretty easy. There are detailed steps, but the overview is:

- Download "fastboot" to your computer
- Power your Nexus on in fastboot mode
- Unlock the bootloader of the Nexus
- Download the Clockworkmod Recovery image
- Write the above recovery image to your phone
- Use the newly written recovery to do things like install root packages, or new kernels, or whatever.

It's really not that complicated or much work at all. There's even a new application that someone wrote that will do all that automatically.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tawheed
Upvote 0
It does have a dual core and better camera/video...you're an impatient guy...5.1 is just around the corner...why not wait instead of blowing more money? GN with big arse screen and dual core, battery life will be worst than 4s, no matter what app you're using to conserve battery. You buy Android for the power, customization, and big screen...you do NOT buy it because it has long battery life!

As of 5.1 beta 3 there doesn't seem to be any reports claiming to improve the life of the battery?
 
Upvote 0
The 4s's battery life has been great for me, the mapquest gps app rightfully killed it at the end though, used the voice navigation with the screen off the whole time because I forgot my car adapter.

photo1.png


photo2.png


With that said, every day I consider trading it for the nexus...
 
  • Like
Reactions: TopherG
Upvote 0
Those are definitely way more impressive numbers than I'm seeing!

I returned my gnex for an iPhone 4s (my first iPhone after MANY android phones) and at first I was super disappointed by the battery life. However, I made some tweaks - especially turning off location services for some apps. Also, turn off Setting Time Zone under settings, locations services, System services. I forget where I read that, but my battery life is much better now.
 
Upvote 0
I returned my gnex for an iPhone 4s (my first iPhone after MANY android phones) and at first I was super disappointed by the battery life. However, I made some tweaks - especially turning off location services for some apps. Also, turn off Setting Time Zone under settings, locations services, System services. I forget where I read that, but my battery life is much better now.

I have location services turned off altogether.. Today my usage is as follows:

Usage 5h 2m
Standby 13hrs 33m

24% remaining
 
Upvote 0
Yes, I'm on 5.0.1. Battery still doesn't seem nearly as good as it did on my iPhone 4. For a device that isn't significantly better I'm disappointed at how much worse the battery is.

I bought my mom a 4S for christmas and it really seems to me that the battery isn't very much better than my GNex. I was shocked to see that after how much people had talked up the iphone's battery life, but maybe the 4S battery just isn't nearly as good as the past versions.
 
Upvote 0
I'd say it's a difficult comparison, especially at the moment with an update on the way that supposedly helps the 4G signal.

4G will drain a battery for sure, and since the iPhone 4s is 3G, it's clearly not working as hard.


That said there are many, many tweaks you can make on the Gnex as well.

I've personally gotten a charge to last nearly 31 hours (mostly on WiFi, few tweaks) and one forum member here got over 3 days I think.

But with any smartphone, I never liked the idea that it would need a charge at the end of the day/night. So having a spare battery ready to go is something I've always done. I just toss it in my bag with my headphones.

Just some thoughts :)
 
Upvote 0

BEST TECH IN 2023

We've been tracking upcoming products and ranking the best tech since 2007. Thanks for trusting our opinion: we get rewarded through affiliate links that earn us a commission and we invite you to learn more about us.

Smartphones