I believe you guys mean Certified New?
Those go through the same exact testing as new phones.
Warranty replacements are Certified New and aren't any more prone to flaws than a new phone.
I know the attachment feeling you have though and can relate.
I am absolutely
not calling you a liar at all, but you
are clearly mistaken.
1)
I believe you guys mean Certified New?
I believe
you mean
Certified Like-New since Verizon doesn't have a "Certified New" designation.
I would argue that "Certified Like-New" is just ad-speak for "Refurbished" or "Reconditioned," since the phones are, you know, refurbished/reconditioned by Verizon before being sent back out.
2)
Those go through the same exact testing as new phones.
For that to be true one of two things would have to happen.
Either:
A) Verizon opens every new phone that they receive directly from any manufacturer and runs it through the same tests as phones that are returned to Verizon, and only then do they send the phone on to a store
Or
B) Phones returned to Verizon are sent to the respective manufacturers to be tested
Verizon's own
Certified Like-New Replacement page doesn't even make that claim.
3)
Warranty replacements are Certified New[sic] and aren't any more prone to flaws than a new phone.
I'd love to see a study on the "recidivism rate" of refurb'ed phones, but unfortunately I only have personal experience to go on here*.
But the fact is that my last phone, an HTC Incredible I purchased new a few days after its release, was rock solid for about 1.5 years. Then it started randomly rebooting.
Once I complained, I went through five (5!?) different refurbs from Verizon. Why five? The first four I got from Verizon were completely unacceptable and I returned those "Certified Like-New" units instead of my original phone that I was trying to get replaced.
Two of them went into boot-loops upon the first boot. One of those never did boot at all, it just went into boot-loops every single time it was turned on. The other would intermittently make it through boot up, but would reboot within a couple of minutes after being turned on.
The micro-USB on another was non-functional so you could neither charge it nor connect it to a PC.
I'd have to check my notes about what was wrong with the other one.
The fifth and final refurb they sent me
seemed to work, but I bought the Galaxy Nexus not long after getting it so I never really had time to put it through its paces.
It seems to me that if anyone at Verizon had so much as powered on these devices
, they would have noticed these problems - at least the one that was completely unable to boot.
I will say that the glass on each of the phones was beautiful, so they obviously do replace that if it shows any wear.
I read somewhere a while back (no idea where it was, so no link - sorry) that the employees tasked with testing refurbished phones are expected to spend an average of about 30 seconds per phone or something ridiculous like that. I don't know if that's true, but given my past experience I wouldn't doubt it.
*One of my favorite sayings is, "The plural of anecdote is not data". Luckily (for "data"-integrity, unluckily for my patience) I had five replacement Incredibles on which to base my observations.