• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Help Buying a normal voice+data plan vs android plan

alok

Lurker
Sep 8, 2009
6
0
With all this talk about people buying the i7500 from Germany; I was wondering if T-mobile has any rules/detection against us using an android phone bought from outside, on the network using a normal voice+data plan like the $30+$10 plan. Because given the price difference of a 2 yr contract ($360) a new phone would in theory need to be over $560 before it is no longer worth buying outside.

So what is the incentive of getting a simlocked phone, that costs more, and be locked into a 2 yr contract?

I guess this applies to some of the other smartphones as well.

TL;DR
Can I buy a phone on ebay and use the $10 data plan? Can they stop me?
 
With all this talk about people buying the i7500 from Germany; I was wondering if T-mobile has any rules/detection against us using an android phone bought from outside, on the network using a normal voice+data plan like the $30+$10 plan. Because given the price difference of a 2 yr contract ($360) a new phone would in theory need to be over $560 before it is no longer worth buying outside.

So what is the incentive of getting a simlocked phone, that costs more, and be locked into a 2 yr contract?

I guess this applies to some of the other smartphones as well.

TL;DR
Can I buy a phone on ebay and use the $10 data plan? Can they stop me?

well, I have web2go $10 plan and I have Galaxy from France. It was unlocked this morning. I've been using it without any problems yet.
 
Upvote 0
If your phone is unlocked or works on your carrier, and you have a SIM from your carrier, you can use it. There is no technical reason you couldn't, unless you have signed something where you agree to only use the phone they've provided (which is unlikely, especially if the carrier has any 'SIM-only' plans available).

The reason they offer locked phones on 2 year contracts are:
- Phone companies love 2 year contracts, they get to hold you hostage for a long time.
- People are tempted by not having to pay upfront for the phone. They either are not smart enough to do the maths in their head or have maxed out all their credit and want to defer the cost.
 
Upvote 0
The issue alok is describing is actually an IMEI filter, so yes, there is a technical reason. If your phone matches their IMEI filter and you do not have their smartphone data plan, then you do not pass go, nor collect $200. I don't know how long it will be (or if ever) until T-mobile adds the Galaxy to their IMEI filter, but when that happens, you'll need a smartphone data plan.

With that said, I currently have a grandfathered t-zones ($5.99-15% discount=$5.09) data plan that gives me full 3G without proxies as the t-zones used to.

I screwed up my SIM card recently and needed my PUK. When one calls T-mobile to request it, they give instructions along with it. They select the instructions based on your phone model. When I called, they knew that I had a Samsung GT-I7500 and gave me the generic Samsung instructions.
 
Upvote 0
The issue alok is describing is actually an IMEI filter, so yes, there is a technical reason. If your phone matches their IMEI filter and you do not have their smartphone data plan, then you do not pass go, nor collect $200. I don't know how long it will be (or if ever) until T-mobile adds the Galaxy to their IMEI filter, but when that happens, you'll need a smartphone data plan.

With that said, I currently have a grandfathered t-zones ($5.99-15% discount=$5.09) data plan that gives me full 3G without proxies as the t-zones used to.

I screwed up my SIM card recently and needed my PUK. When one calls T-mobile to request it, they give instructions along with it. They select the instructions based on your phone model. When I called, they knew that I had a Samsung GT-I7500 and gave me the generic Samsung instructions.

hey,

do you mind sharing your APN setting? I have the web2go unlimited and seems very slow...i only get 0.5 MB...
but my TM506 gets 1.5MB...something's not right..
 
Upvote 0
hey,

do you mind sharing your APN setting? I have the web2go unlimited and seems very slow...i only get 0.5 MB...
but my TM506 gets 1.5MB...something's not right..

I copied it from a friend's G1. I haven't tried a data test at full signal strength yet, so I couldn't give you a number. Also, do you mean Mb(bits) or MB(bytes)? Maximum theoretical under T-mobile HSDPA is 7.2Mb/s (iirc), which would equate to somewhere around 0.9MB/s.
 
Upvote 0
I copied it from a friend's G1. I haven't tried a data test at full signal strength yet, so I couldn't give you a number. Also, do you mean Mb(bits) or MB(bytes)? Maximum theoretical under T-mobile HSDPA is 7.2Mb/s (iirc), which would equate to somewhere around 0.9MB/s.

I just got 0.42 mbps 424 kbps my edge speed was somewhere around 0.23 mbps
I was expecting more than 0.42 mb
something's not right...
 
Upvote 0

BEST TECH IN 2023

We've been tracking upcoming products and ranking the best tech since 2007. Thanks for trusting our opinion: we get rewarded through affiliate links that earn us a commission and we invite you to learn more about us.

Smartphones