• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Application to record all income/outcome voice calls

Mehdi 100

Lurker
Mar 28, 2015
2
0
Hi there. Regarding call recording, I have two questions to ask. First, is there any software to record both carrier phone calls and calls on social networks ( ex. Viber, line,..)? Second; If the answer to the first question is 'No', can I install two recording software on my cell phone( One for recording a regular carrier phone call and the other for viber/line... )?. In my experience during installing a call recorder, the app provider claimed that no one should install more than one call recorder, as they may interrupt each other. Is my scenario an exception to this claim/rule? (My cell phone: samsung galaxy note 4, n910c-android 4.4.4- the smartphone is not rooted). I'd like to record all telephone/data (voice)conversation on my phone.

Thanks for your attention.
 
The answer to your first question, IMO and experience you can record the transaction of the social network with screen recording app. Depending on which rom you're using, some custom rom comes with their own screen recording app such as the pac - rom and blissStalk are the two I know of. The app can record what goes on in your screen with the same resolution as highest your device can put out, and even record the sound. The second question, IMO and experience is device depend end. Because of the controverse surrounding recording the conversation without the other party's concent, certain devices make it very difficult to record the conversation through the phone mic. Which means a lot of time it had to be done with the speaker phone, which gives a lots of echo. But there are many phone recording apps in the play store that claim to work, but IMO many of them are hit or miss depend in on the device. If you have a Samsung device, you may have a easier time to really record the phone conversation. Also, if you have cm based rom installed, you can also try the XPosed module that can turn on the phone recorder in the rom.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Like I said, phone recording is a controversial issue and device dependent. Most of phone recording app that suppose to work is usually done with the speaker phone, but if you want to do that, you can build your own app with the Tasker app, instructions is on their the ways to use the Tasker web site. I remeber my Window mobile phone and earlier Samsung media phone like legend(remeber that one?) all come with phone recording function. Only on Android phone recording seems to be a taboo issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mehdi 100
Upvote 0
The app I linked is far better than speakerphone tricks, etc.
The issue is less taboo and more about kernel issues depending on the main processor.
That dev has made great strides to fix that even without rooting.

I have just downloaded and installed the app. It looks great-especially the minimal design of it, but it was not free! The free version does not support automatic call records which is the number one essential function of the this kind of apps! There are plenty of software to automatically record calls but this one needs somewhere around 10 US dollars to do that

I have to admit that I am not a professional user and do not know whats and whats of android phones. Anyway if there is any decent (free) software to match my needs, please introduce it to me.

Thanks a lot.
 
Upvote 0
You're right about the kernel. Somebody else told me that awhile back. Why is that if it isn't some kind of conspiracy?
Yeah, ok. Let me toss out something, see what you think.

Out here in the Southwest USA, we got us some ranches and we have a thing called Occam's Razor.

Occam's Razor is good at slicing up questions under the idea that the simplest answer is usually the right one.

If I were to blindfold you and drive you out a ways onto the range, eventually we'd hit a spot where I could turn off the motor and you could hear some galloping and what might sound a little bit like a miniature stampede.

You would be right if you said, in theory, that noise could be a bunch of zebras and a heap of yaks.

But the simplest idea would likely be the correct one - that would be the sound of horses and cattle. (We actually have zebras and yaks in the Great Southwest but your chances of hearing them are really slim.)

I've been reading from various devs for three years why you can't do call recording on my phones blaming the processor, kernel, or both.

Now if I look at that app, read about what he had to go through just on my phone model, and a bunch of combinations to try just to get my version of my phone to work, then it's pretty easy to conclude that supporting this just for one model isn't a walk in the park.

Now, suppose my phone maker decided to offer this?

In addition to my model, they make a lot of others. Now we're talking about real engineering, testing and support time.

Plus, what do they do if it breaks some other feature?

After all, it's not like it's just magically included in their kernel and then they threw the off switch.

Plus - their international corporate legal staff would get to charge extra because call recording is restricted in a lot of jurisdictions.

Where I am, I have to ask for permission first, then turn it on, then verify that I have permission to record the call. (So, no to the OP, just being on automatically all of the time isn't obvious to me being something that we all want ok.)

Now - add up all of those costs and take your best guess at how many people would care about this feature for the expense and then after involving marketing after all of the above and before you're ready to sell it, how much have you driven up costs and cut in to profits?

And how much extra would people be willing to pay?

I got a market sample of one that really wants it but says $10 is too much.

Plus what do you say when your competition's marketing department accuses you of putting out a sneaky spy phone that doesn't respect anyone's privacy? Whose side do you think the press will take with juicy click bait like that?

This could all be a conspiracy. I can't prove or promise it's not.

But I think that the conspiracy sounds like zebras and old fashioned cost and profit control sounds like horses. ;) :)
 
Upvote 0
... The free version does not support automatic call records which is the number one essential function of the this kind of apps! There are plenty of software to automatically record calls but this one needs somewhere around 10 US dollars to do that ...

I can't understand people who want an app that is "essential" to them but aren't willing to spend any money on it. It's either "essential" or it's not .....
 
Upvote 0

BEST TECH IN 2023

We've been tracking upcoming products and ranking the best tech since 2007. Thanks for trusting our opinion: we get rewarded through affiliate links that earn us a commission and we invite you to learn more about us.

Smartphones