• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Some questions on the S9 camera

peterh337

Android Enthusiast
Mar 24, 2015
311
24
Hi All,

Currently I have the S7. I am looking at buying an S9 and wonder if the camera app has solved some of the issues which the S7 app has:

1) Can it be configured so it shoots raw and jpeg concurrently, and the setting is saved, and you get it every time you start the app with the shortcut (double press on the Home button? - I know there isn't one, so how is it launched?)

2) Can it write stills and videos to the SD card? The S7 app cannot, if you shoot in raw. Only 3rd party apps can (I use Footej Camera) but these cannot be opened with the button shortcut. Admittedly this is less relevant since there is a 64GB version of the phone.

3) Can one still do a USB transfer to a PC i.e. the phone appears as a USB drive? The S7 can.

Many thanks in advance for any feedback.

It seems to me that the S9 is the best phone camera out presently, unless you want to accept tradeoffs e.g. Iphone X (IOS, very expensive), Huawei P20 (no 3.5mm jack and no wireless charging), etc. I just need raw pics, which come out nicely in Lightroom with a bit of processing, avoiding the "Samsung photo" over-saturation and over-sharpening :)

Peter
 
Yeah, nobody bothers to post much useful stuff on any of these (many) android forums, and on XDA the only people who know anything are rather arrogant hackers :)

AFAICT, having got the S9, the answer is that it is same as the S7. The camera is the same too - exactly the same picture quality, both jpeg and raw.

The best phone camera is definitely the Huawei P20 PRO, and I did some photo comparisons

https://www.euroga.org/forums/websi...anywhere-as-good-as-a-dslr/post/186734#186734

but that doesn't have wireless charging which for some is a PITA. The next version will have it :) But that phone will also not write jpeg+raw (or even just raw) with a quick-launched camera; I am beginning to believe that is some dumb android limitation imposed by google. Presumably on a rooted phone you could edit some XML file to change the quick-launch camera app to some 3rd party one like Footej which unlike the stock app does actually work as it should.

Also it appears the Iphone X cannot do this either (write raw with a quick-launched camera app).
 
Upvote 0
Compared to a DSLR and a tripod yes, all phones are bad in low light. But I've been surprised at how much better they have got in recent years.

I'd not go as far as to say that any is the best though, and certainly would not add the word "definitely" to such a statement. They all have their faults, and these will matter more to some people than others. The P20 Pro's "AI" processing can certainly produce some awful results in circumstances where others easily do better, and unless they've improved it a lot from when it was released this is the first thing I'd turn off.
 
Upvote 0
The changes to the S9 camera compared to the S7 is basically only with regards to low light performance. They have an onboard DRAM for faster image processing in certain modes, the variable aperture to let in more light in low light situations and bigger pixels on the sensor. That's about it. So the change in quality is almost all software side which will be apparent probably only when you adjust manual settings, but I wouldn't expect it to be largely noticeable.
 
Upvote 0

BEST TECH IN 2023

We've been tracking upcoming products and ranking the best tech since 2007. Thanks for trusting our opinion: we get rewarded through affiliate links that earn us a commission and we invite you to learn more about us.

Smartphones