Sorry if this is slightly off topic but I thought I'd share my screen protector experience thus far.
My first attempt at a screen protector was a phantomskinz. I liked its feel but after install it had speckles that would not go away even after a week. I also hated installing it with water.
I got the Clarivue screen protector and love it so far. Installed it without water, which I feel is the best way to install a screen protector, and have zero dust. It looks just like stock glass but as they suggest on their site, it is slightly smaller then the screen as was intended.
Overall, I'd say that the clarivue protector is almost the same in feel, and clarity to the phantomskinz but may be ever so slightly thicker. It is cut slightly smaller then phantomskinz, width wise, but neither protector is a perfect fit and it would probably be far less then a millimeter difference in total.
I'm willing to ignore the speckling issue on the phantomskinz and with that in consideration clarivue still wins because of its installation. You do not risk having water on your screen with an open earpiece. It's all personal preference I suppose. In the end it comes down to whether you want to install using water or spend a few more dollars.