1. Are you ready for the Galaxy S20? Here is everything we know so far!

Annoying Phandroid pop-up

Discussion in 'Suggestion Box & Feedback' started by shmn, May 21, 2011.

  1. shmn

    shmn Android Enthusiast
    Thread Starter

    Lately, when surfing these forums on my EVO, a pop-up comes up and asks if I want to download the Phandroid app. I downloaded but much prefer to use the browser and traditional web site. But that pop-up comes up whenever I return to the Android forums. How can I get rid of that pop-up? I still have the Phandroid app installed...I just don't use it. I hit "Cancel" but it's getting old.

    1. Download the Forums for Android™ app!


  2. Kelmar

    Kelmar Done by choice

    Moved to Site Suggetion/Feedback so that the Admin can see it.

    I agree that it's annoying though. Perhaps it's something where it only shows up when you aren't logged in or on the first visit of a certain period of time or ....
  3. Rob

    Rob Galaxy S20 Ultra
    Phandroid Staff

    Hey shmn - thanks for the feedback. The dialogue box SHOULD set a cookie and only show once every 30 days. Is your browser set to accept cookies? If not, that's the reason. If so, I'm not sure what the problem is. Can you check into the cookies or any other details you may think of and report back?

  4. shmn

    shmn Android Enthusiast
    Thread Starter

    I'm using a stock EVO with stock browser. Accepting cookies is on. This morning I got that dialogue box twice so far on four page loads on these forums. I am automatically logged in when I come to the forums. Should I clear my cookies and cache? Thanks for the help.
  5. Kelmar

    Kelmar Done by choice

    Rob - I can confirm that this pops up each time the browser is pointed to af AND when the browser has been fully closed (backing out, task killer or reboot).
  6. Rob

    Rob Galaxy S20 Ultra
    Phandroid Staff

    Thanks for the info. Our developer will be in shortly. I'll have him look at this and report back when we think it's fixed. Then hopefully you can confirm.

    I think letting people know is a valuable thing (about the app), but this is just obnoxiously annoying. In your opinion though, what would be the optimal middleground? Is once every 30 days okay? Or more than that?
  7. Kelmar

    Kelmar Done by choice

    IMO, 30 days is very fair.

    I usually use the app for day to day browsing but there are times when I prefer the browser (polls, reporting posts, moderator controls, etc).
    NightAngel79 likes this.
  8. shmn

    shmn Android Enthusiast
    Thread Starter

    30 days sounds good. But if you ever hit "ok" on the dialogue and download the app, it should stop asking...is that possible to do?
    woop, NightAngel79 and Kelmar like this.
  9. NightAngel79

    NightAngel79 Bounty Hunter

    Good Point!!
  10. Roze

    Roze Hiding behind a mystery

    I think this is definitely fair. If a member already has the Phandroid app on his/her phone, there's no point asking them to download it (again and again).
  11. TVictory

    TVictory Well-Known Member

    I have made some changes to the algorithm used to determine when to show phandroid app suggestion popup. It is live on the sites now, you should not see the popup more than every 30 days (or until cookies are cleared).

    If this algorithm works out and we don't get any major bug reports, i can add some logic to deal when someone clicks on [OK].
  12. Bob Cat

    Bob Cat Careful, They're sharp!!
    VIP Member

    I've used the app for so long that I didn't think to use the browser and go to the site to do those things since there's no tools yet in the app. Thanks
  13. gcobb

    gcobb Android Enthusiast

    It's funny how whenever there's an ad that blows someone's browser out of proportion that the developers need to be contacted. Does Internet Brands run this site too?

    And threads I haven't responded in or read in months show updated. When I look, I got updated because there is an AD. Go figure.

    If I wanted to go to Phandroid, I wouldn't have put in this URL.
  14. Phases


    I think there's some confusion here. THIS pop-up being referenced has to do with our Phandroid App, letting users know we have one. The code and algorithm used for this is developed in house - so yes tweaking it requires our developer.

    The actual ads, which includes a recent one that had broke browsers - are controlled by our ad network and the only way those can be fixed/changed are when Rob gets on the phone with them. He is on the phone with them a lot.

    As for the threads showing updated. I do not believe that to be because of ads, but because recently I set the time limit VB uses to automatically mark threads as read from 10 to 45 days (if I remember correctly).

    Internet Brands has nothing to do with us and other than owning VB - never will.

    As for the last sentence - I don't understand.

    I appreciate your feedback but if you're going to come guns-a-blazin' at least read the thread and be consistent with the conversation.

    NightAngel79 likes this.
  15. TVictory

    TVictory Well-Known Member

    It seems even with the change the Popup Everytime it still effecting the EVO, I haven't seen mention of any other device having the problem.

    I don't have access to an EVO and I have not been able to replicate the issue myself.

    I am going to turn off the popup now.
  16. Phases


    I think the Nexus was mentioned on that +1 post..
  17. Kelmar

    Kelmar Done by choice

    Still happening on my Epic as well but not every time (seems random).
  18. Roze

    Roze Hiding behind a mystery

    I saw it happening on my Atrix yesterday. Not sure when was the last time I had the popup since I mostly use the app on my phone.
  19. shmn

    shmn Android Enthusiast
    Thread Starter

    I haven't seen the pop-up since TVictory made the changes. Thanks for the prompt service!
  20. Timanator

    Timanator Well-Known Member

    I have seen the popup twice in the past 2 weeks. And I have been logged in the whole time.
  21. Timanator

    Timanator Well-Known Member

    Just got it again after clicking back while reading a thread.
  22. woop

    woop novacane (OFWGKTA)

    What mobile device are you using?
  23. Sak01

    Sak01 Android Expert

    Just now, I was getting the popup on every single thread or forum category I click on. Fortunately, my firefox noscript has kicked in to save the day.

    This is on my pc
  24. woop

    woop novacane (OFWGKTA)

    I think you're referring to a different pop up than the one being referenced in this thread. Yours would be an actual ad which is something you would need to contact Phases about so that he can talk to Rob. The one in this thread is the actual Phandroid App pop-up I believe.
  25. Sak01

    Sak01 Android Expert

    Yeah, it was actually an ad. It's stopped now anyway.

Share This Page