I made the switch. As long as you know you will need to root the phone the software will be close with the edge going to the incredible. However, the screen on the fascinate rocks and is worth it.

 

They are pretty similar, minus the battery life. I also think the camera/video is better on the Fascinate. If you like your DInc & want a bigger screen, wouldn't the DInc 2 be the perfect fit? lol

 

See my sig. End of story.

 

I have owned both the Incredible and the Fascinate. I think both are great, I would say root wise I still prefer the Incredible, just because of better options out there for ROMS. But the Fascinate is a real nice phone after being rooted.

Battery life for me was a lot better on the Fascinate than the Incredible, and I liked the bigger screen. I would say either phone is a good choice!

 

I also just went from the D-inc to the Fascinate(bought the SF off contract from a user on this forum) and I must say that I so very impressed by the SF. Bigger screen(4 vs 3.7), better screen(Samoled vs amoled), lighter, thinner, bettery battery life(1300mah to 1500mah) and better GPU(Cortex A8, same as iPhone4). Only real draw back to me is no decent GB rom yet. Other than that it is amazing and I plan to sell my Dinc soon. PS it needs Root.

 

Nevermind.

 

I made the same switch, the bigger screen was the reason I made the switch, the SF is wider and made it much easier to type on.

 

I have a dinc now and I'm tossing up either the fascinate or Droid x, I'm after better battery life mostly

 

I've been using the Fascinate now for a couple of days and I think I'm going back to my DINC. The battery life seems to be much worse on the SF. I've been playing with different radio files trying to find one that doesn't drain to zero in a matter of hours. So far EA28 seems to be the best but I'm getting ready to try DL09 next. The screen is nice but not that much different than the DINC. it's still pretty tough to see outdoors.