*This product is also compatible with the OEM 2000mAH extended life battery for Galaxy Nexus GSM but is not compatible with Verizon 2100mAh extended life battery for LTE version.
Definitely go with the following Diztronic Matte case sold by Amazon. It's cheap, professional looking, has all of the proper cut-outs for ports / buttons, and as slim as it gets without compromising protection. The case is designed for the standard battery, but since it is not a hard case, it works perfectly well with the 2100 battery. This case will not disappoint, I assure you. It has protected my phone very well and the matte finish looks great.
As mentioned previously, the Rearth Ringke Slim is a fantastic minimalistic case that does not go over the edges. I have had mine for a couple of weeks and really it.
$26? You guys have expensive tastes. Amazon.com: rearth ringke slim case galaxy nexus