If you're unable to load CWM 4.0.1.5 and are still on CWM 4.0.1.4, then TWRP is definitely the way to go. CWM 4.0.1.4 cannot charge while power is off. That right there would be a dealbreaker for me, and should be a concern for anyone else.

However, if the newest version is available and you're doing a comparison, I like CWM a slight bit better. TWRP didn't clear out my batt stats properly. I don't know if that's only my unit or other people see it as well. But it's organized a little better and is more noob-friendly, IMO. Except if you select the wrong thing. Sometimes it doesn't let you back out. Like I forgot to wipe my dalvik one time, and had already selected to flash a zip from SD card, I couldn't exit back to the menu to wipe dalvik. I never liked that about TWRP. But, like I said, it is organized a little better and is customizable, to a degree. And the customized way of doing backups is neat.

CWM does everything it needs to do, does it well, just is not organized in a way that you would expect.

 

The latest version of cwm is perfectly fine...especially if you are used to it. If anything, the cwm folks have been continuously modifying their product and I think the .05 version works great. Anyway, have used them for over a year and never a problem.

 

Yep, I used ROM Manager. I don't really use ROM Manager for anything else but it sure makes it easy to keep your cwm up to date. Your very first choice when opening the app is "Flash Clockwork Mod Recovery". ANd below it it should display your current version of recovery in small print. At the top you will see ROM Manager 4.3.3.0...just realize that is only the version of ROM Manager and has absolutely nothing to do with the version of recovery you are running or are about to flash. A lot of people used to get confused about that.

 

Now you're pushing it!!!!

 

Twrp.

 

Indeed! Hands down!

twrp FTW!


CWM sucks... I wont get into why... But I will list just a couple reasons why I like twrp....


1. This is the most important for me... (im a rapid flasher) It has a check box to aut reboot on completion of flash. I dont have to baby sit the ROMS I am building. One automated step that saves me alot of time.

2. It has themes.

3. Its by teamwin

Thats all for now. Like I said I have personal angst with the developers of CWM.


teamwin FTW!

(Also keep in mind: This really a Ford vs Chevy debate, all said, they do the same tings)

 

While I use CWM, thanked and quoted for being 100000000000% correct. I don't think you can *really* go wrong either way.

To be honest, the only reason I went with CWM is because it was the incumbent, and is a proven commodity having been around for so long now.

 

I had an issue where a NANDroid made with TWRP 1.0.0 could not be restored with TWRP 1.0.2. I'm chalking it up to new-release glitches, so in the meantime, I'm using CWM.

I do prefer the extra functionality of TWRP, though I can also understand that CWM is extremely portable between devices because they don't go too crazy with adding new features.

 

Okay so i read all of your replies. Can we get to a bottom line on this?

I am new to rooting and have used neither CWM or TWRP at this point in time.

It sounds to me like TWRP may be a bit easier to start out using... But from what a couple of people have said it has crapped out on them when updating...

NANDroid backups are extremely important so if they stop working im going to be screwed...

 

twrp

The back up issue the mod referred to was due to incremental changes in the recovery itself. Kinda like if you upgrade from XP to Win7 you may a glitch with your backed up files not being compatible (best example I can think of, sorry). Now that they are on 1.0.3 and have not changed for weeks this point is 100% mute.

twrp is easier to use (user friendly), has more functionality and you can change the way it looks...

What more can I say, I am fanboy of teamwin and I never heard of them until the 3D.

 

I like twrp and cwm about the same although I wish there was a way to not wipe my ext4 partition with a data wipe

 

A lot of people prefer CWM because they can use ROM Manager with it. When I rooted and flashed on my Optimus S you couldn't use ROM Manager, you had to manually go into recovery and flash everything manually regardless of what you used. I got accustomed to that and it is good to know because if you don't and can't get to your screen for some reason you still know how to get to recovery. Imho if you are going to root and mod your phone you also need to be familiar with adb so you can access your device when all else fails and the experts here are trying to help In short, while some may think TWRP is not as convenient I personally prefer it because it is very stable and you aren't as prone to getting lazy

 

I went with twrp because it seemed like the main devs were pushing it and I want to run what is going to be supported in the years to come from the beginning.

I did make a cwm backup as soon as I got rooted and then I switched to twrp and did the same before I made any changes to anything. This way I have an unmodified backup in both so I should be covered no matter what.

 

Never let your manual skills get rusty.

Are airline pilots forgetting how to fly? - Business - msnbc.com

 

I used twrp when it was first released and ran into a few problems. I liked twrp a lot, but decided I'd stick with cwm until all the bugs were worked out.

Sounds like it is more stable now, so it might be time to switch back.

 

Better yet...how many people still multiply in their heads vs using a calculator?

 

Lol how many people know how to make change without looking at the cash register or when you give them the extra penny to make it even?! You would not believe how many times I have been in line paying in cash and the person is thrown off because I paid something like $12. 01 for something that cost $11. 96 and got the deer in the headlights look

 

it looks no different that their previous recovery. perhaps just bug fixes maybe more menu items havent gone through it all