I spend very little time on the homescreen. Games, movies, and browsing, and anything you do off the homescreen, its much better.
I current use both of these handsets.
One for work, one for personal use.
Fascinate is my personal phone.
Honestly, no kidding, I scoff at my Incredible when I have to use it.
Battery life is much poorer on my Incredible.
I have an under-volt kernel and custom ROM on the Incredible too.
There are ZERO widgets that update or programs that run in the background.
It's purely work-only calls and occasional e-mail.
Now that I've been using the Fascinate for a couple of weeks, the Incredible's screen seems so inferior in comparison.
The only thing I like about the Incredible is the optical trackpad.
Otherwise, in my opinion, the Fascinate is better in every regard.
(They're both awesome phones though.)
There is no LED notification. You can get sound and vibrate notification of course. Or try a 3rd party app like NoLED: NoLED - Android app on AppBrain free in Marketis the main difference between touchwiz and sense that touchwiz scrolls left to right instead of up and down? i like the left to right scroll better.
also, i don't care about the bing search but is there a way to get google calendar and google maps?
lastly, someone wrote in a verizon review that there is no notification for a new text. is there a way to change that?
There is no LED notification. You can get sound and vibrate notification of course. Or try a 3rd party app like NoLED: NoLED - Android app on AppBrain free in Market
well i got the fascinate today for my wife. i've owned the incredible since launch. now, given that i've only had a day with the fascinate, take this with a grain of salt...
get the incredible. it is a FAR better phone. the fascinate has many, many issues:
1) no notification leds
2) contact management is COMPLETELY f**ked. syncing gmail contacts is useless as the phone will only see internal phone contacts for basic tasks such as custom ringtones or creating groups. you need to basically douplicate your contacts to get these things to work
3) the phone does not recognize gmail contact group lists
4) laaaaag. damn this phone is supposed to have a kick butt processor, but you'd never know it from navigating around the phone. sometimes i've had to wait upwards of 10 seconds before a shortcut would appear on a home screen after i've added it
5) no calendar widget. at all
6) bing voice search is hardwired into the search button and is terrible
7) bing search is ok but its no google. no google widget with stock handset
8) email issues galore. first off, it defaults to sync with your accounts NEVER. took 2 hours to figure that one out. second, for some reason when you open outlook on the desktop, you emails on the phone disappear. ok...
9) when creating a calendar entry, you are forced to choose each and every time between the phone's calendar and your google calendar. the phone calendar, like the contacts, are an island unto themselves and do NOT sync at all with your google info
10) gps takes a good 2-4 minutes to find a signal in either of the navigation apps. that's ridiculous
there are some good things too (screen is breathtaking), but as of now the negatives far outweigh the positives. its just a half baked phone at this point. i assume most of these things will be fixed down the road, but the dinc as of now runs rings around it in every category except 1) battery life and 2) display quality/size
get the incredible. it is a FAR better phone.
1) no notification leds
2) contact management is COMPLETELY f**ked. syncing gmail contacts is useless as the phone will only see internal phone contacts for basic tasks such as custom ringtones or creating groups. you need to basically douplicate your contacts to get these things to work
3) the phone does not recognize gmail contact group lists
4) laaaaag. damn this phone is supposed to have a kick butt processor, but you'd never know it from navigating around the phone. sometimes i've had to wait upwards of 10 seconds before a shortcut would appear on a home screen after i've added it
5) no calendar widget. at all
6) bing voice search is hardwired into the search button and is terrible
7) bing search is ok but its no google. no google widget with stock handset
8) email issues galore. first off, it defaults to sync with your accounts NEVER. took 2 hours to figure that one out. second, for some reason when you open outlook on the desktop, you emails on the phone disappear. ok...
9) when creating a calendar entry, you are forced to choose each and every time between the phone's calendar and your google calendar. the phone calendar, like the contacts, are an island unto themselves and do NOT sync at all with your google info
10) gps takes a good 2-4 minutes to find a signal in either of the navigation apps. that's ridiculous
Hmm. I am not seeing those issues at all that are not easily overcome with my Fascinate. I compared Fascinate, Dinc, DX, and D2 in the store and chose Fascinate. I wanted a screen that could be read in broad daylight. Fascinate won that by a mile. After conditioning the battery I get a good 12-15 hours. GPS never takes more than 2 minutes to lock. Usually about 30 seconds. I have google search on soft key and google voice search, google nav and maps. Using Jorte, I easily set default calendar and easily sync contacts, appointments, tasks with google calendar and to Outlook 2003 on my PC. (Using gsyncit) Gmail contact groups are recognized once you go in and select the groups you want to use. You can choose whether you want contacts on phone only or on gmail as well. Email was a breeze to set up with my ISP server and with gmail as well. I really prefer NoLed to having physical LEDs like my old WinMo. Nor have I experience much lag. Now I have not used the Inc for these purposes, but I can't imagine it being much easier. In short it seems to me that nearly ALL of your criticisms are bogus. Maybe it isn't the phone that is "half baked" but the result of operator error in not taking the time to dig into the settings. I came to the Fascinate from the wonderful world of WinMo so I had a steeper learning curve I guess than someone already familiar with Android, yet I see none of the problems you state that are not quickly and easily remedied after studying the remarkable, helpful info on these forums.
is the main difference between touchwiz and sense that touchwiz scrolls left to right instead of up and down? i like the left to right scroll better.
also, i don't care about the bing search but is there a way to get google calendar and google maps?
I don't think I would mind not having an LED notification since I do not have one right now. As long as the screen lights up to let me know I have a text and who is texting me, I will not have a problem.
I am very inexperienced with google accounts. I just created a gmail the other day for when I decide on which phone I will be getting. I only know about four people with google accounts and android phones so I do not think all of these issues will pertain to me. I will just be adding my university account to my phone anyway, which is the email that everything goes to.
sorry for all of the questions, as I mentioned before, I am an inexperienced user and just trying to do my research before I spend my money. Thank you for the answers!
yeah google search on soft key is great. but that's not the complaint. it's that the hard key is hardwired for bing.
also, i don't care about the bing search but is there a way to get google calendar and google maps?
What hard key? Every type of search I do on my Fascinate now goes to Google, including a voice search, so you're confusing me here ....
.
Does the SF sync directly with Outlook?
Seems weird that a "google" phone doesn't play nicely with google contacts.
I get very good battery live out of my Incredible after the first week of conditioning it. Now six weeks later battery run times are long & consistent under heavy use.I don't agree with the Dinc battery issue. Mine can go almost 3 days with basic .
I get very good battery live out of my Incredible after the first week of conditioning it. Now six weeks later battery run times are long & consistent under heavy use.
no it doesn't. the incredible comes with something called htc sync, which enables direct syncing with outlook calendar and contacts. the fascinate comes with no such utility.
so after a weekend's worth of research, the only thing anyone's been able to come up with to overcome samsung's google contacts and groups issues are to duplicate your gmail contacts on the phone as well. you can export/import them to the phone contact list to basically create another contact list that the phone will recognize. once you do that, you can link the phone contacts with your gmail contacts and can use custom ringtones, recreate your groups, etc. it's cumbersome to say the least, but it works.
apparently the upcoming froyo update will have a bunch of firmware fixes for the fascinate, one of which is to have google contact groups recognized by the phone (#25 in the leaked changelog here
I9000XXJPC Change log and bugs - xda-developers
I get very good battery live out of my Incredible after the first week of conditioning it. Now six weeks later battery run times are long & consistent under heavy use.
My signal strength with my Fascinate has been terrible lately. I am getting 0-2 bars in my apartment while my girlfriend (who has a Droid X) gets 3-4. Because of the low signal strength, call quality is ass, web browsing and app downloading is slow. Also this slight echo of my own voice when I make phone calls is starting to get annoying. I went to Verizon, thinking it was problems with my own phone, and they gave me a new phone. The problems persisted, so I am thinking of getting an Incredible because the Droid X is just too big for me (yes, and I know that is what she said).
We've been tracking upcoming products and ranking the best tech since 2007. Thanks for trusting our opinion: we get rewarded through affiliate links that earn us a commission and we invite you to learn more about us.