1. Check out our companion app, Forums for Android! Download from Google Play

Gizmodo asks the Question of the Day: iPhone 4 or HTC EVO

Discussion in 'Android Devices' started by zpilot, Jun 7, 2010.

  1. zpilot

    zpilot Well-Known Member
    Thread Starter
    38

    Jun 4, 2010
    237
    11
    38
    Link to page: iPhone 4 vs EVO 4G

    So I was reading one of the comments and found it quite interesting:

    "Evo doesn't even belong in the same poll with iPhone 4. They are superficially similar if, say, you look at the head-to-head comparison Wired did. But closer consideration shows a huge difference.

    First is the build quality and level of engineering in the iPhone. Apple's design has had time to mature and HTC's hasn't. You have to consider the case integrity, component quality, etc. not just superficial form- factor.

    Second, Apple is historically conservative on specs. If they say 7 hours talk time, you can expect 7 or more. When other manufacturers say 6 they mean most likely 4 and 6 if you are lucky.

    Third, Apple's huge IP portfolio gives them an engineering advantage. For example, maybe HTC opted for an 8MP camera to make a marketing claim, but maybe the materials cost caused them to cut corners elsewhere. Apple tends to create balanced, pragmatic designs and use clever engineering to do more with less.

    Finally, Apple has the industrial design thing down. Their products are unique, sexy and inviting to use. The Evo's design is derivative of every other plastic bar phone out there. You might as well compare a Mercedes (Apple) to a Toyota (HTC)... both fine cars, but not really comparable." by funakoshi.gichin.shotokan

    What are your thoughts?
     

    Advertisement

  2. colnago

    colnago Well-Known Member
    243

    Nov 17, 2009
    3,091
    218
    243
    I think that if the new antenna works as Apple hopes, there may be less complaints about AT&T's network.
     
  3. Covert_Death

    Covert_Death Well-Known Member
    213

    Feb 2, 2010
    2,091
    665
    213
    Male
    ELP Engineer @ National Instruments
    Austin, TX
    lol

    hog wash. the iPhone doesn't compare to the EVO in my opinion, to each his own but the build quality of the EVO is top notch, no complaints here. as far as iPhone design having "time to mature" that is BS, apple has been in the phone buisness for 4 years. creating 4 phones... htc has been in it ALOT longer and has moved with the times and has created HUNDREDS of phones

    it's just an apple fanboy comment and everything he says is opinion... which he is entitled too, but NOTHING is fact that has been stated
     
  4. Android 17

    Android 17 Well-Known Member
    113

    Mar 30, 2010
    575
    176
    113
    Funny that you put an entirely Apple-positive statement there, I'm not sure if you intend to troll or not, but you're clearly on the line there.

    If this is clearly supposed to be a fair discussion, why not mention anything about the EVO except for the thread title?
     
    willnj, misterzeno and Bluesun_EVO like this.
  5. gezzuzz

    gezzuzz Well-Known Member
    16

    Jun 6, 2010
    85
    3
    16
    and apple please dont sue us..
     
  6. IPvFletch

    IPvFletch Well-Known Member
    43

    Jun 6, 2010
    441
    28
    43
    Austin, TX
    Apple spent more designing it than HTC did. But arguably HTC has built dozens of phone models while Apple has only built 3.

    All I know is, we need to SPREAD THE WORD and get Android up above iPhone on this one!! :)
     
  7. sean76

    sean76 Well-Known Member
    213

    May 5, 2010
    4,460
    779
    213
    THE BOSS
    NYC
    My man, while some of your claims are true, your on an Android forum! And if I was a moderator I would close this thread because your going to get SLAMMED from every direction. I happen to like Apple and its products, however there new OS is more of the old just meant to look new. And while they might win on build quality and having a true blue 5 mega pixel shooter, what good is any of it if the network is just plain Terrible. It's like having a Porsche, but with a tank of water instead of high octain gasoline.

    The comparisons are going to get heated. But what I can say is this, Android is a fire breathing monster, and they are going to continue to just grow and get bigger everyday. The same with HTC, there phones are going to continue to improve with every outing. Sorry to bring the truth, but my EVO IS UNBELIEVABLE right now out of the box, and when Froyo gets released for the EVO, WOW is all I have to say!
     
    McBong, zaaye, wase4711 and 4 others like this.
  8. rjjr2531

    rjjr2531 Well-Known Member
    43

    Sep 23, 2009
    271
    45
    43
    dallas,tx
    the new iphone seems great but not too innovative...i actually use 4g regularly on my evo and iphone wont have it...id prefer a much bigger screen over a higher reolution smaller screen...better cam on evo...i do like the longer battery on apple....but again, androids os is so much better had has so much more potential to be a lot better....free tethering on evo too...

    i think in the end of the day, the customizing and the screen size of the evo win me over...
     
    AM2 likes this.
  9. thezlog

    thezlog Well-Known Member
    16

    May 5, 2010
    69
    6
    16
    I'm very strongly considering jumping off the EVO ship.

    I spent months looking forward to this phone. MONTHS.

    Typing on this thing is a nightmare. It cannot keep up with me. My iPhones and winmos and blackberry phones have always kept up, but both my phone and my wife's phone are not able to keep up with how fast i can type.. missing letters and such. I've been told by friends that have the moto droid that they've always had that problem and that "i should type slower/more carefully". Eff that.

    Battery life is horrendous. I've done with and without a task killer, but the bottom line is I don't want to have to kill tasks, turn off GPS, BT, WIFI, 4G, or other things so that my phone will make it through the day. I'm not even doing that much. I haven't used the phone much today and the silly thing is down to 20%. On a busy day it would not survive.

    I'm really depressed about the EVO. I was so hopeful for it and so excited to jumping away from Apple and the iPhone. Now it looks like I'll be going back to them. I just can't deal with the keyboard lag. I've tried other keyboards and no use. Wiped phone twice and no resolution.
     
  10. zpilot

    zpilot Well-Known Member
    Thread Starter
    38

    Jun 4, 2010
    237
    11
    38
    Just by looking at the poll, there are many iphone fans... Will android ever become that mainstream?
     
  11. geomens

    geomens Well-Known Member
    16

    May 16, 2010
    98
    6
    16
    Government worker
    South Florida
    Jump ship already. It looks like this is not the phone for you.
     
  12. thezlog

    thezlog Well-Known Member
    16

    May 5, 2010
    69
    6
    16
    lol bitter much?
     
  13. adseguy

    adseguy Well-Known Member
    53

    May 11, 2010
    164
    50
    53
    My thought is they are both the best phones on the market PERIOD. Each have there own nuances.

    Overall it comes down to this:

    -Apple has an easier to use phone that simply works and works well. You can't get advanced with it, but that's the price you pay for simplicity.

    -Android has a much advanced UI and experience. You can customize and make it do a lot more, but it's not simple and you have to keep watch over it, but that's the price you pay to get a full featured phone.

    people will still scream and shout "My phone is better" on both sides and guess what they are both right, because it's right for THEM.
     
    willnj, zaaye, orionquest and 13 others like this.
  14. adseguy

    adseguy Well-Known Member
    53

    May 11, 2010
    164
    50
    53
    Sorry to hear that. I'm coming from an iphone to and I type REALLY fast as well. I say give it some time. I'm still not typing to 100%, but I am getting better as the days progress, plus I feel the Android is a better predictor on the word completion. Give it another week or so then it you are still unimpressed switch over. You'll still have a great phone!
     
  15. cooper1010

    cooper1010 Well-Known Member
    93

    Mar 31, 2010
    504
    176
    93
    swype?!
     
  16. RaiseUp151z

    RaiseUp151z Well-Known Member
    43

    May 23, 2010
    200
    32
    43
    I would say EVO 4g is a Maserati & the iphone is a Mercedes station wagon.

    take your pick....
     
  17. horadin

    horadin Well-Known Member
    58

    May 1, 2010
    180
    21
    58

    Why does that make him bitter? You sound like the bitter one in your post.
     
  18. shamsy

    shamsy New Member
    5

    May 27, 2010
    3
    0
    5
    if you are having issues with texting try out swype with your EVO
     
  19. zpilot

    zpilot Well-Known Member
    Thread Starter
    38

    Jun 4, 2010
    237
    11
    38
    Well, see swype isn't exactly typing...
     
  20. GaryColeman

    GaryColeman Well-Known Member
    53

    May 28, 2010
    244
    99
    53
    Interesting.
     
  21. farrellcollie

    farrellcollie Well-Known Member
    16

    Jun 6, 2010
    80
    4
    16
    I do not understand all the polarization. I am on sprint and have a family plan and I like the evo. To change to att would cost us more money and I hate the att/apple restrictions, but the iphone is a great phone too for many things. In my area iphone gets good reception and is easy to use. I like playing with my phones so evo is fun for me and I am getting good battery life - I can go 24 hours or more on a charge (so much better than on my touch pro - which I admit is not saying much) and good reception on the evo. I really do not think one is accross the board better than the other phone based on preferences and needs.
     
  22. bobTX10

    bobTX10 Well-Known Member
    18

    Apr 30, 2010
    77
    23
    18
    I thought swype wasnt available yet until the beta opens back up. Is there another way to get it on the phone?
     
  23. raqball

    raqball Well-Known Member
    93

    Jun 2, 2010
    523
    155
    93
    You can't do much on the iPhone 4 with AT$T new date caps...

    Nexflix on the iPhone 4... Hahahha... You better not use it...

    AT&T Data Calculator
     
    Complex757, KoukiFC3S and twospirits like this.
  24. rushmore

    rushmore Well-Known Member
    323

    Nov 13, 2008
    8,267
    1,355
    323
    Kentucky
    Hmmmm. Sounds like Gizmodo is doing some SERIOUS sucking-up to right their transgressions a few weeks ago.
     
    wase4711 likes this.
  25. mas90guru

    mas90guru Well-Known Member
    16

    May 2, 2010
    79
    6
    16
    Sage MAS90 Accounting Software Consultant
    CT
    I've always said that Android is best for heavy Google users.
     
Tags:

Share This Page

Loading...