HELP, Which one?! HTC One 32GB vs. LG Optimist G Pro


My phone (HTC Vivid) recently came down with the "I'm not going to charge" disease. Long story short, I'm upgrading my phone and trying to decide. I believe I have narrowed it down to the HTC One 32GB vs. LG Optimist G Pro (If y'all have any other suggestions they would be more than welcome (At&t user)

Basically I like them both, leaning a tad more towards the HTC One but can't find anything to warrant spending $100 more to upgrade than the LG.
I like the features on each of them. Especially the size and long battery life of the LG. Along with the availability of cases and general features of the HTC.

Help me I am stuck between a rock and a hard place, suggestions please?

P.S. I have played with both of them; there are things I like and dislike about both of them


share the love peeps ;)
Which one makes your geek-soul say "mmm" when you look at it? A couple of nice cases will cost you $100 so the "wow" factor is important i think (not "wow" to other people, just that "wow" you get when you see a pretty gadget) :)