1. Are you ready for the Galaxy S20? Here is everything we know so far!

I really don't know about Android....

Discussion in 'Android Devices' started by brykins, Dec 6, 2009.

  1. brykins

    brykins Android Enthusiast
    Thread Starter

    Been one month now with an HTC Magic on Vodafone UK. It's a work phone and was an ideal chance to investigate Android before my own upgrade is due in February.

    I'm currently using a Blackberry, have in the past used Windows Mobile devices and an iPhone so have experience of all my options.

    I really wanted to like Android. I like the idea of open source smartphones and having a choice of hardware but it's just not living up with what I was expecting:

    WiFi - very hit and miss. My Blackberry and iPhone both (a) let's me connect to a hidden WiFi network and (b) never drops the connection. The Magic (a) won't connect to a hidden WiFi - I have tried the hidden SSID app and that didn't work and (b) connects to the WiFi but if I leave the phone for any time, then it drops the connection. WiFi is still on, but not connected and I have to manually re-connect. Not good.

    Productivity apps (Calendar, notes, contacts) are simply not up to scratch compared to Blackberry and also to a large extend, to iPhone. Lack of desktop syncing seems to be a problem especially with regard to syncing notes. I don't use a Google address or calendar or contacts and don't want to sync to those.

    Market Place is good - compared to Blackberry. BB app store is awful, slow, expensive and there's very, very little on there. iPhone....well - miles ahead of the Android store in numbers, most apps seem a lot cheaper and most of the ones I tried were better - more finished/polished.

    Other things that wind me up are the lack of any way of deleting the deleted items in the email app - they have to be deleted individually which seems daft and there being no way to re-order the apps in either the main "app screen" or in folders that are placed on the desktops.

    I still have two months, so we'll see what happens with app development, but for me, the lack of apps and the standard of market place and the productivity apps and syncing are real downers.

    But then I don't want to stay Blackberry as the app development there is almost totally dead. I don't really want an iPhone as the lock-in is just too much with Apple saying what we can and can't do.

    1. Download the Forums for Android™ app!


  2. mjschmidt

    mjschmidt Android Expert

    I used to have this problem with Ubuntu until they fixed it in 9.04, so maybe it's a Linux thing and Google just need to get around to fixing it. I had the same problem with my phone, but I just set my SSID to broadcast at home, and haven't yet met the need to get on a hidden WiFi net anywhere else.
  3. brykins

    brykins Android Enthusiast
    Thread Starter

    We have a work WiFi set to hidden (serviced office, we're supposed to buy 1 x 2Mb connection for each user....at
  4. mjschmidt

    mjschmidt Android Expert

  5. brykins

    brykins Android Enthusiast
    Thread Starter


HTC Magic Forum

The HTC Magic release date was May 2009. Features and Specs include a 3.2" inch screen, 3MP camera, 288GB RAM, MSM7200A processor, and 1340mAh battery.

May 2009
Release Date

Share This Page