OK I know this was discussed with Lolipop, but I'll post a follow up so others can tell us what they have done to date to resolve this issue from LP
I finally updated to LP, since I will be receiving my S5 sometime next week from the FIL, so I wanted to test drive LP, to see if I like it first, so when the S5 gets it, I'll decide whether to update or not.
So far it takes getting use too, but for the most part I have no issues with LP. But this sound issue urks me, I like to turn the volume off for notification every night, between certain hours, now from what I can see, BC of the way Google changed this process, it looks like no apps will allow us to do so any longer. Now I know if we press the volume down button, we have options and scheduling that we can set according to preference. The issue I have is it does not always work as described. I have all notifications turned of, but calls from caller ID to come in. When my call did come it, it did not ring, and the notifications did silence, but I did not get any Led display telling me I had a notification for either a TM or an Email. Thanks Google for deciding this, and not leaving it up to us to choose.
One more thing, I thought the star notification in the status bar, is for when a schedule is set, why is the star always on now ??
So after all the discussion and complaints from many, has anyone figured a solution to this without having to root, otherwise when I get the S5, I'm not updating BC of this.