Phone Contacts App Not Syncing with Google Contacts

Android 6.01 on LG56VL

If I add a contact on the Web interface of Google Contacts, It appears instantly in my phone Contacts app on my phone. But if I add a contact on the phone, it never appears on the Web Google Contacts.

In other words I am only able to do a one way sync. Contacts added to my phone don't sync with Google Contacts.

I've gone through the phone settings and everything I was able to find related to syncing for the Contacts app seems to be enabled.

Anyone know what the problem is? Thank you for any help!