Accessories Seidio Active vs. Casemate Tough Case

[jynx]

Looking for a hybrid case with rubber covered by plastic. I have pretty much narrowed it down to these two cases. I have heard a lot about the Seidio and have heard good things except problems hitting the power button and volume button as well as the corners not fitting snug. I have barely heard anything about the case mate. I am leaning towards the case mate tough case. What do you guys think is better quality?

 

[jynx]

ended up with the case-mate. heres a review

http://androidforums.com/evo-4g-reviews/235121-review-case-mate-tough-case.html

 

[chrischoi]

That looks really thick. I ordered the Seidio Active. Hopefully it's not thick.