1. Are you ready for the Galaxy S20? Here is everything we know so far!

This is pretty cool

Discussion in 'Computers' started by nickdalzell, Jan 12, 2013.

  1. nickdalzell

    nickdalzell Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    Linux toying around has landed me Android within Linux...one way to get Netflix to run in Linux is to run Android inside of Linux and use the Netflix app. but this is still too cool! something about using Linux ignites this itch in me to play around in it--sometimes bringing it to a grinding halt or finding neat ways to run operating systems inside of it and more--easier than running a VM in Windows. i couldn't pull this off easily in Win8


  2. mikedt

    mikedt 你好

    I believe Netflix uses Microsoft's Silverlight(Why? $$$ from Microsoft?) rather than Flash for in-browser streaming on a PC. Of course MS only makes Silverlight for Windows, nothing else.

    Can't try it myself, as Netflix is US only.
  3. nickdalzell

    nickdalzell Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    the app installs and runs in the SDK emulator but i wonder if it will have sound. all the notification tones are nonexistant so i cannot test until i view a video through Android on top of Linux. not sure what is included in the SDK androids, if sound is even enabled or how i'd go about it. right now i'm just giddy that i got it to boot up

    EDIT: Netflix does run, i get audio but NO video playback. the emulator is running Android 4.2 not sure if that has anything to do with it...i'll see if it runs in 4.0 and let you all know.

    here's another screencap, looks more like i'm running a widget on top of Linux:

  4. MoodyBlues

    MoodyBlues Compassion is cool!
    VIP Member

    Does Netflix not work on [Linux] browsers with Moonlight installed?
  5. nickdalzell

    nickdalzell Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    Sadly, Moody, the moonlight plugin does not work. i don't think it supports the method of DRM that Silverlight does--yet

    Silverlight will install successfully in wine, but it will give a player error 1001 when attempting to play a video.
  6. MoodyBlues

    MoodyBlues Compassion is cool!
    VIP Member

    Ah, I see. Oh well, I have Amazon Prime which includes streaming movies, TV shows, etc.--and it works on ALL computers. :D
  7. nickdalzell

    nickdalzell Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    it would not work on my smartTV where most of my Netflix time is used though :(

    i tried Hulu Plus which runs in Linux but it hasn't nearly the library of TV shows that Netflix does (it lacks Star Trek which is a deal breaker for me) plus Hulu Plus's bandwidth requirements are so high my internet connection (wireless system in the country) is not good enough and i lack the provisions for cable/DSL so i cannot get higher speed.

    Hopefully the Moonlight plugin will get an upgrade soon though, but so far i've found the one thing an Ubuntu distro cannot do as of yet. i'm still converting some of my apps over...still trying to diagnose the lack of video playback on the Android app though...sound works great

    Pear included a very nice CD burning application, has a great selection of current web browsers, and the version of Wine included may satisfy some of my games but i will need to find a faster hotspot first to find out
  8. mikedt

    mikedt 你好

    Amazon Prime uses Flash, that's why it works on most major OSs. While Netflix uses MS's nasty Windows only Silverlight thing. Netflix is owned by Amazon....did MS pay Netflix a bribe or something?
  9. mikedt

    mikedt 你好

    Chances are Moonlight with never support MS's Moonlight Digital Restrictions Management(DRM). No doubt how it works and how to implement it is a Microsoft proprietary trade secret, and is subject to draconian NDAs. Like most things from MS. :rolleyes:

    Moonlight is a community developed open source project, based on the public specification that MS publishes for Silverlight. it uses no MS code. Rather like what Mono is to MS's .NET framework.

    You could always run Windows in a virtual machine from Linux, like Virtual Box. Or boot into Windows when you want to watch Netflix.
  10. palmtree5

    palmtree5 Sunny Vacation Supporter!

    Is it really or is it that Netflix uses Amazon services for their IT infrastructure and probably pays a lot of money for it
  11. Speed Daemon

    Speed Daemon Android Expert

    Although I'm an accomplished Linux user/admin, and have plenty of spare PCs that I could use for Netflix and other services like it, I've found that buying one of those little ~$50US video appliances that are sold everywhere from Best Buy to Wal-Mart save me the headaches of using a full-blown computer OS, and then having to stay vigilant about patching all of the vulnerable software (Flash, Java etc.) to keep the bad guys out.

    BTW, if you haven't heard already, Java has been exploited, and you should turn it off in your browser until the next release comes out on Tuesday (which is what Oracle has promised).
  12. MoodyBlues

    MoodyBlues Compassion is cool!
    VIP Member

    I wouldn't do that. For several reasons. First, of course, I have no copies of windoze nor would I want any. :rolleyes: Not going to dirty my network with that garbage. :eek:

    Second, I've been vigilant for decades about expressing my unhappiness with companies who were M$-centric. Remember when many web sites REQUIRED Internet ExploDer in order to access them? I wrote to every single one and told them I don't use M$ garbage, including its INSECURE, non-standards compliant, crap browser, and I wouldn't give them my business until they programmed their sites so all browsers could access them. I used to point them to the AnyBrowser.org web site, too. :D Do you know how long it's been since I encountered an IE only web site? Me either! It's been so long it's a vague memory now. But that's because people like me complained.

    So when a company like Netflix refuses to acknowledge and program for Linux users, my choice is to protest by A) letting them know WHY I'm not a customer and, B) NOT using some workaround to use their service. I've been saying for eons that when Linux users do something like dual boot windows so they can access a particular site, all that does is ENCOURAGE that site's belief that Linux users are insignificant. You know what I mean? If all they see in their logs is M$ visitors--even though SOME of those are actually Linux users, only reluctantly booting windoze to access that one site--they're NEVER going to change.
    Davdi, Speed Daemon and argedion like this.
  13. nickdalzell

    nickdalzell Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    i am trying to ditch Windows in favor of Linux. and it seems a bit offstandish to have Windows running within Linux. what i do not understand is how the Android Netflix app gets around the DRM requirement. another thing i do not get is why it refuses to behave in the Android SDK emulator. everything else works, including the sound, games, other apps, etc. i get sound in Netflix, the pause/progress/volume bar but no video whatsoever.

    i may not use it often but there are times when i'd like to finish watching something on there when i have my laptop with me, where a Roku won't exactly fit--such as on the go, at mom's, while at the laundramat, near a public hotspot, etc. for now i'll just have to use my Jelly Bean tablet.
  14. 9to5cynic

    9to5cynic Android Expert

    Or just leave it off for good :p I mean, we know it's only a matter of time (i'd bet not too long) until the next sploit comes out for it. :D ;)

    As a user of ancient internet access, I am immune to these high speed streaming problems... but I do like the solutions you guys have come up with for working around the limitations of Netflix. :)
  15. mikedt

    mikedt 你好

    It does have DRM AFAIK. More than likely it's an encrypted H264 stream and the decoding is handled by the app itself. It doesn't use Silverlight, that's certain.
  16. nickdalzell

    nickdalzell Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    sadly my solution didn't work. I get audio but no video. the only workaround is to carry my tablet with me and use the Android app
  17. mikedt

    mikedt 你好

    I wonder if there's money or some other backhanders or kickbacks involved? Something like Micro$oft is paying $$$$$ to large commercial organisations like Netflix to use their Silverlight?

    A few years ago when the BBC first started their iPlayer on-line viewing and streaming service. They were using Silverlight. There was one hell of a stink about it. I think even the UK Government became interested as well. About how a state funded public broadcaster was supporting Windows only. The BBC iPlayer now uses Flash, and AIR for off-line viewing, and works just fine with Linux, Windows and Mac OS X. They also have Android, Blackberry OS, Windows Phone, Symbian and iOS iPlayer apps as well.

    From 2007.
    What tricks is the BBC up to with Microsoft? ? The Register

    "What tricks is the BBC up to with Microsoft?

    Conspiracy, iPlayer, and DRM"
    MoodyBlues likes this.
  18. saptech

    saptech Android Expert

    I believe Moonlight is a dead deal.

  19. MoodyBlues

    MoodyBlues Compassion is cool!
    VIP Member

    Well, micro$oft needs to figure out--pretty soon, I'd say--that they are NOT god. Their mobile phone sales are in the toilet; holiday sales reports I read only discussed Android and Apple, they didn't even mention windows. Samsung recently canceled plans to release a windows RT device in the US because of "modest demand" for machines running the scaled-down version of the micro$oft operating system. I believe that Linux is now the most used operating system on the planet; of course that includes the wildly successful Android we all love here, but still, it is Linux.

    M$ needs to wake up and smell the coffee. They're shooting themselves in the foot with idiotic decisions like the Moonlight issue. One of these days stupid sites, like Netflix, will realize that sticking with an M$-only model means they're shooting themselves in the foot, too. :rolleyes:
  20. Speed Daemon

    Speed Daemon Android Expert

    OpenSUSE uses IcedTea by default, and has other Java alternatives available to it. I'm not certain if the exploit affects IcedTea, but better safe than sorry. ;)
  21. dirtbikerr450

    dirtbikerr450 Member

  22. nickdalzell

    nickdalzell Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    don't thank me, this method did not work. it would let me use the Netflix app, it would load up, show my Instant Queue and let me select an episode. but all i would get is audio but a blank screen and no video. the playback controls would work but no video. never did figure out why.

    neat if you want to mess around with Android and Android specific games while running Linux though
  23. Davdi

    Davdi Android Expert

    I've never been tempted to stream movies on a PC/Tablet/Phone. The only movies I stream are via cable TV to a nice big 1080p LED TV. I do use Google Play Music and Amazon MP3 quite a lot though. All we need in the UK now is WiMax everywhere and an in-car player that's compatible.
  24. nickdalzell

    nickdalzell Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    do in-car (add on maybe) TVs offer an HDMI input? if so there are some Android tablets with HDMI out, assuming you can get a connection on them while moving, you should be able to stream that way?

    RadioShack does offer an A/V to HDMI/HD converter for $80 you can use to make the same thing work in older vehicles with ye olde CRT screen (older full-size vans)
  25. Speed Daemon

    Speed Daemon Android Expert

    In general, a TV, with a built-in ATSC tuner and/or DVD player, generally doesn't have HDMI inputs. But HD monitors that are meant for in-car installation often do have HDMI inputs.

    To put it another way, factory-installed video screens: probably not. Aftermarket installed video screens: just specify that you want one with HDMI in.

Share This Page