1. Are you ready for the Galaxy S20? Here is everything we know so far!

Verizon S4 warranty returns? Be honest

Discussion in 'Android Devices' started by -=Jeff=-, Sep 16, 2013.

  1. -=Jeff=-

    -=Jeff=- Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    How many of you S4 owners have had to exchange your phone for some issue or another.. I am just trying to determine what phone I want and the other phone I am looking at is the MAXX and I know how Motorola's track record has been with me with the Droid X and droid bionic.. My RAZR MAXX had been okay until recently


    1. Download the Forums for Android™ app!


  2. wtherrell

    wtherrell Android Enthusiast

    Not me. Had my Dev Edition 2 months now. Running Hyperdrive rom. Happy as a Skylark.
  3. CrimsonPride

    CrimsonPride Android Expert

    as the galaxy s4 is the top selling android phone, i can safely say most people have not had problems with their phone.
  4. CimBa07

    CimBa07 Newbie

    The only issue I've had is one time I left it in my room and when I came back and grabbed it it was running super hot. The battery had also significantly drained itself. I'm not sure why. I restarted it, and it hasn't done it since. Hopefully it won't happen again and I won't have any other issue with it.
  5. -=Jeff=-

    -=Jeff=- Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    Just because it is top selling does not mean it is issue free..
  6. fascinated

    fascinated Well-Known Member

    I think the latest Maxx will better than previous. I have both previous Maxx's. The camera sucked but the battery life and call quality was awesome. Android on the Maxx was also really close to stock Android which I liked. Camera is good on the S4 but battery is nowhere near the Maxx.
  7. lotus49

    lotus49 Android Expert

    Considering the millions of S4s sold and the relatively tiny number of people here, you are not going to get any useful indication of the level of problems from 20 odd responses.

    No phones are free of problems but the S4 is a great phone that stands comparison with anything available at the moment.

    You should choose the phone that is right for you based on the feature sets of the two not on a statistically insignificant bunch of replies on a web forum, but FWIW (i.e. nothing) mine has been faultless.
  8. -=Jeff=-

    -=Jeff=- Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    I know just gauging opinions that's all..
  9. lotus49

    lotus49 Android Expert

    I have been following this forum since the phone came out. There have been a few people who have had problems but my perception is that it is very much in line with previous phones I have had both from Samsung and Apple.
  10. allanlaw

    allanlaw Android Enthusiast

    To actually answer your question, yes, I had to exchange my first S4 for a new one due to the overcharge-shutoff situation that I posted about.
  11. CrimsonPride

    CrimsonPride Android Expert

    It does not mean it is issue free, but it gives a very good indication.
  12. -=Jeff=-

    -=Jeff=- Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    Yes it does. I am torn between the Motorola Maxx and the S4..
  13. itsallgood

    itsallgood Android Expert

    How true. I have had mine since June and the only issue I had, was not enough internal memory in the 16GB version. Took it back for the 32GB version and love it. (I'm on AT&T)
  14. speedlever

    speedlever Android Enthusiast

    No phone is perfect. Choose the one you want and go for it.

    That being said, I exchanged a perfectly good GN2 for a perfectly good GS4/16 for a perfectly good GS4/32. ;)
  15. -=Jeff=-

    -=Jeff=- Android Expert
    Thread Starter

    That is just it. Need to pick a phone I know will last 24 months, it does not seem like any really do.

    The S4 positive is the battery can be replaced but I don't want to be tied to a charger if possible..

    My RAZR Maxx I have now will last one day, it has degraded quite a bit in the last year.

    The MHL option of the S4 is also a positive.

    Just unknown how we'll the radio is compared to Motorola
  16. speedlever

    speedlever Android Enthusiast

    Some folks still live with and love a dumb phone. How can you go wrong with any of your choices? Analysis paralysis can keep you out of a perfectly good and functional device. And since individual usage varies widely, what works best for one person may not be the best choice for another.

    The choice has to be yours.
  17. Crashumbc

    Crashumbc Android Expert

    Historically Moto has better radio's (although I've hit a few dude phones)

    One of the reasons I'm a BIG fan of replaceable batteries, is given that cell phone batteries get used heavily, you should expect the battery's performance to degrade about 20-30% minimum over a year. That's ANY battery in any phone.
  18. lotus49

    lotus49 Android Expert

    All of mine have. I have had 5 smartphones and I am still using two of them (iPhone 5 and S4) so I can't say about those but I am prepared to bet they last two years just as my previous three (two iPhones and an S2) have and indeed, were in excellent condition when I sold them without a mark on them and still fully functional in every way.

    No smartphone has what used to be regarded as good battery life (my last feature phone's battery lasted 5 days easily) but as long as it gets you through a day, that's good enough. One really positive feature about the S4 is the removable battery. I carry two charged batteries around with me in my bag and it takes about a minute to swap batteries. Try doing that with an iPhone or an HTC One.
  19. jlb0305

    jlb0305 Android Enthusiast

    i had an issue when i first got the phone with callers hearing an echo on their end. exchanged the phone within first 3 days and haven't had an issue with the replacement. Phone is awesome just make sure you put a screen protector and case on it. Quality of plastic case is low and it gets damaged easily with light drops w/o a case. As for screen its gorilla glass which makes it harder to make big scratches but little ones are easier than most screens (first one scratched before the 3 days even when it was only thing in my pocket). Spec and use wise, this is leaps and bounds above my Incredible or Rezound.
  20. fascinated

    fascinated Well-Known Member

    Having had a 1st and 2nd gen Maxx and now an S4 I'd go with the current gen Maxx simply based on the interface, battery, Motorola radio alone. Quite honestly the S4 touchwiz interface is annoying compared to the Maxx interface which is really close to vanilla android.
  21. Adara

    Adara Android Enthusiast

    I think it is probably hard to figure since it's still relatively early with respect to the phone's release. I mean, I had no problems with my Bionic at all, until one day, a number of months in, it just dropped dead. Fully charged battery; phone wouldn't turn on. But there were no signs of problems before that. I think it's still too early to tell with the S4 whether this thing will be solid.

    As for the radios, the best thing I can say is to find a friend or neighbor your area with each phone and see for yourself how the reception is. When I had the Bionic, it couldn't hold a 4G signal in my house to save its life. I took a test drive of an s3, and it had 4 solid bars. So moving to the Galaxy line from the Motos was sort of a no-brainer for me. But that's just my own personal living room -- ymmv.

Samsung Galaxy S4 Forum

The Samsung Galaxy S4 release date was April 2013. Features and Specs include a 5.0" inch screen, 13MP camera, 2GB RAM, Exynos 5410 Octa processor, and 2600mAh battery.

April 2013
Release Date

Share This Page