1. Check out our companion app, Forums for Android! Download from Google Play

Voice Recognition Censorship

Discussion in 'Android Devices' started by skwerl, Jul 12, 2010.

  1. skwerl

    skwerl Member
    Thread Starter
    16

    Jul 7, 2010
    24
    2
    16
    Why does Google insist on turning "George Carlin's Seven Dirty Words" into "####, ####, ####, ####, ####, ####, ####"?

    I see no reason that my voice recognition software should CENSOR my speech.

    Any comments?
     

    Advertisement

  2. tjwoo

    tjwoo Well-Known Member
    53

    May 22, 2010
    218
    50
    53
    Which google censorship are you talking about?
    I just spouted some expletives in to my phone using the google voice search function, and sure enough pulled up google searche results containing such expletives.
     
  3. dgaf98

    dgaf98 Well-Known Member
    38

    Jun 1, 2010
    76
    10
    38
    Phoenix
    mine shows #### #### too! its dumb
     
  4. skwerl

    skwerl Member
    Thread Starter
    16

    Jul 7, 2010
    24
    2
    16
    I should have elaborated.

    When I use the BUILT IN VOICE DICTATION on my HTC Evo for text messages or emails, George's Seven Dirty Words come up all #s.
     
  5. tenma

    tenma Member
    16

    Nov 28, 2009
    11
    1
    16
    It does this to avoid potentially offending people if it incorrectly identifies something you are saying as an obscene word.
     
    skwerl likes this.
  6. skwerl

    skwerl Member
    Thread Starter
    16

    Jul 7, 2010
    24
    2
    16
    Tenma, I understand what you meant to say, however, it is illogical.

    If Google, or Android, does not want to OFFEND PEOPLE then they should assume OFFENSIVE words are NON-OFFENSIVE words.

    I.E. - If someone says, "Sh*t", it should appear "sheet".

    Any one else care to comment on GOOGLE'S CENSORSHIP?
     
  7. Braaainz

    Braaainz Well-Known Member
    53

    Jun 7, 2010
    347
    85
    53
    I think they're doing the smart thing. By censoring out the words, you know their software is working correctly, but they're hedging against any accidental mis-translations.

    If they substituted words, people would say their voice recognition wasn't any good.
     
    skwerl likes this.
  8. skwerl

    skwerl Member
    Thread Starter
    16

    Jul 7, 2010
    24
    2
    16
    Braaainz, I do like your reasoning.

    However, I, the user, should be given an option to toggle "offensive" or "non-offensive" language/speech. Otherwise, they are still censoring my speech; digitally.

    What if Google does not know how to spell offensive language? Perhaps, any unknown words are spelled in #s.
     
  9. Braaainz

    Braaainz Well-Known Member
    53

    Jun 7, 2010
    347
    85
    53
    They are not censoring you though. You are still free to use the keyboard to type out your expletives. If they made it impossible, THEN you might be able to make the claim.
     
  10. SolApathy

    SolApathy Just another robot
    VIP Member
    333

    Jun 1, 2010
    1,817
    1,424
    333
    Male
    IT
    Ohio
    Sounds like it's time for a new app/mod to change that.
     
    skwerl likes this.
  11. skwerl

    skwerl Member
    Thread Starter
    16

    Jul 7, 2010
    24
    2
    16
    Braaainz: FINE! They may not be completely censoring me, but its is truly annoying not to have an OPTION for "offensive" dictation.

    SolApathy: Here, here!!
     
  12. dr g

    dr g Well-Known Member
    93

    Jun 7, 2010
    589
    187
    93
    Apparently on 2.2 there is an option to turn the censorship off.
     
  13. emicarri

    emicarri Member
    16

    Jun 2, 2010
    11
    4
    16
    from what I understand...froyo 2.2 is supposed to fix this issue and speech recognition will stop censoring cuss words. I've read this on a couple of websites, so I'm pretty sure it's true, but we won't know for sure until EVO gets the 2.0 upgrade.
     
  14. Rob_A

    Rob_A Well-Known Member
    113

    May 28, 2010
    831
    216
    113
    New York
    I drop f bombs when texting certain friends. It does get a little annoying but nothing too serious. A toggle would be nice for the easily offended.
     
  15. Rigmaster

    Rigmaster Well-Known Member
    143

    May 4, 2010
    1,584
    220
    143
    I don't care that it catches the words. I do care that it sometimes censors when I'm not cursing. I don't send curse words in emails or texts, so I find it a little annoying that the software assumes it.

    If I wanted to curse in an email or text, speech recognition wouldn't stop me though!
     
  16. mynamewastaken

    mynamewastaken Well-Known Member
    73

    May 31, 2010
    302
    81
    73
    I don't think that word means what you think it means.
     
  17. apocalypse_later

    apocalypse_later Well-Known Member
    38

    Jun 9, 2010
    112
    11
    38
    This exists to stop situations where you meant to say one thing but something else comes out. "Hey mom that duck last night was great" could be pretty problematic if the voice to text got "duck" wrong. Regardless, 2.2 will let you disable this, so relax.
     
  18. thespasticone

    thespasticone New Member
    6

    Dec 15, 2010
    2
    1
    6

    I have this issue too!

    Someone do me a favor, and in your evo say "kid free night", or even just "kid" and tell me if it is censored or if this is just my issue. .
     
  19. marctronixx

    Moderator
    623

    Oct 12, 2009
    5,722
    3,547
    623
    34.0522° N, 118.2437° W
    have you adjusted the voice recognition settings in the language and voice screen in settings?
     
  20. thespasticone

    thespasticone New Member
    6

    Dec 15, 2010
    2
    1
    6
    Sorry I just got my evo a couple of days ago, and just found out the censoring is now optional! That is awesome, I can talk about my "kid free night" again!!

    Thanks for the reply!
     
    marctronixx likes this.
Tags:

Share This Page

Loading...